Most Read: Lifestyle

All We Can Eat
Posted at 12:30 PM ET, 03/22/2012

Beer Madness: Readers’ vs. judges’ picks

The ‘elite eight’ brews have emerged from our annual Beer Madness competition, which has been marked by decisive victories and relatively
Greg Kitsock and the Beer Madness judges taste and record their thoughts on this year’s field of brews. (Instagram user Carannk)
few close calls. Our panel of judges seems to be in agreement on the superior beers so far, with only four 5-4 splits in the first round and two in the second.

But while judges appear to be on the same page with their picks, readers have disagreed with a few of the panel’s decisions.

In the first two rounds, readers voted against Maui Coconut Porter, selecting both Lucky 7 (in Round 1) and Allagash Black (Round 2) over the porter. Sierra Nevada Stout has suffered the same fate. Despite six votes from the panel in the first round, the Sierra Nevada product lost to Schlafly Oatmeal Stout among readers.

The most jarring discrepancies between readers and judges have come over a trio of beers: Three Philosophers, Bell’s Lager and Eliot Ness Amber.
Greg Engert of Church Key tallies the judges’ votes during Beer Madness. (Instagram user Carannk)

In the first round, Bell’s Lager crushed Fordham Helles Lager, 1329-786 in online voting, despite losing in the judges’ final tally. Three Philosophers likewise dominated Siamese Twin, 1190-344, but couldn’t convince the judges to pick it over the lemon grass-flavored Siamese Twin.

In the second round, Eliot Ness triumphed over Fordham among online voters without advancing to the final eight among judges.

Have you agreed with our panel’s verdicts? Tell us in the comments below and cast your vote for the ultimate brew in our interactive bracket.

More on Beer Madness:

Hometown brew makes it past second round

Defending champ Fordham Helles Lager survives first round

A style guide to this year’s field

Beer Madness: Craft brew descriptions

Meet the Beer Madness judges

By Cara Kelly  |  12:30 PM ET, 03/22/2012

Categories:  Beer | Tags:  Cara Kelly, Beer Madness

Read what others are saying

    © 2011 The Washington Post Company