Most Read: Local

Posted at 10:45 AM ET, 08/07/2009

NOAA Says No to DHS Hurricane Modification

* Major Heat by Sunday: Full Forecast | NatCast | July Recap *

As we reported in May, more than 25 years after termination of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Project Stormfury, which aimed to weaken hurricanes by seeding clouds with silver iodide, the Department of Homeland Security has been attempting to involve NOAA in establishing a hurricane modification program of its own.

Given the dubious results of past research and a host of other concerns, NOAA appeared unwilling to provide the critical support the DHS program requires.

The rebuff by NOAA is now official.

Keep reading for more on NOAA's rebuff of DHS...

A letter dated July 29 to William Laska, program manager for DHS's Advanced Research Projects Agency, from Richard Spinrad, director of NOAA's Office of Atmospheric Research (OAR), states, "While OAR recognizes that weather modification, in general, is occurring through the funding of private enterprises, NOAA does not support research that entails efforts to modify hurricanes."

NOAA's position and rationale, as laid out in the letter (PDF) made available by OAR, is essentially the same as described in my earlier post. Namely, the DHS proposal was inconsistent with NOAA's priority of mitigating the toll of hurricanes on life and property through improved forecasts, warnings and preparation -- not hurricane modification.

Is this the last word? Maybe not. Sen. Kay Bailey Hutchison (R-Texas) recently introduced The Weather Mitigation Research and Development Policy Authorization Act of 2009. The legislation proposes appropriations of $25,000,000 for each of the fiscal years 2010 through 2014 to the National Science Foundation. Of this, 34 percent is to be divided and transferred to NASA and, yes, NOAA.

The legislation speaks only of weather modification in general without specifically mentioning hurricanes. However, this press release makes clear Hutchison's intentions to "mitigate the impact of severe climate and weather events, particularly hurricanes and storm surges." At a recent Senate hearing (which I attended) on Weathering the Storm: The Need for a National Hurricane Initiative, Hutchison reinforced her intentions but left no hint that she was aware of the DHS program and NOAA's rebuff (watch Hutchison speak).

Spinrad testified at the hearing, but deftly avoided answering direct questions about his thoughts on hurricane modification.

By  |  10:45 AM ET, 08/07/2009

Categories:  Government, Government

Read what others are saying

    © 2011 The Washington Post Company