It’s been 69 years since a knuckleballer started an All-Star game.
But given a prime opportunity to break that streak, National League manager Tony La Russa instead extended it to 70.
Dickey, who is in the midst of a season for the ages, had hoped to get the nod, and on Monday expressed disappointment in La Russa’s selection.
“I’m not going to break down in tears over it, but at the same time I’m a competitor. I want to pitch. I want to start,” Dickey said. “I feel like I had a good enough first half that I should be considered. But I’m not the boss. I don’t necessarily have to agree with him, but I have to respect it. That’s just the way it is.”
Should Dickey have gotten the ball over Cain? Here’s a look at how the two compared over the first half of the season.
Dickey --- 12-1---- 2.40 ---- 0.93 ---- 123 --- 26 --- .203 ----- 2
Cain ------- 9-3 ---- 2.62 ---- 0.96 ---- 118 --- 24 --- .209 ----- 2
The feather in Cain’s cap was his perfect game against the Houston Astros on June 13. Dickey, meantime, tossed consecutive one-hitters, including one on the same night as Cain’s masterpiece.
“We wanted to reward Matt Cain for a career of excellence that’s getting better and better,” La Russa said of his choice. “And he had a great example of that during the summer on one of his pitching days.”
Cain will be paired with his regular battery mate in Giants catcher Buster Posey, who La Russa said may be pulled in favor of Phillies backstop Carlos Ruiz when Dickey takes the mound. But the 37-year-old Dickey hopes his nearly-extinct style — he is the only knuckleballer left in the majors — didn’t factor into La Russa’s decision.
“You’re talking about the best players in the world, and you’re asking about a pitch that’s too nasty to handle?” Dickey said. “I hope that’s not it. If that’s the reason, that’s a poor reason.”
But simply making the team is quite a feat for a pitcher who never made more than 15 starts or had an ERA below 4.62 in his first seven major league seasons. After committing to the knuckleball, he has become the Mets most consistent starter over the last three seasons and he is a key reason why the team went into the break six games above .500.
And Dickey could very well play a key role in helping the NL take home-field advantage for the World Series.
But the question remains: did he deserve to start? Did La Russa snub Dickey or is this all just sour grapes?