The MLB home run derby should not take as long an MLB game


(EPA photo)

Major League Baseball tinkered with the home run derby format this year, putting the hitters in brackets because maybe it would make everyone think of March Madness, I guess. But the rule changes — combined with an hour-long rain delay — did nothing to change the fact that the event is an overlong bore that either needs to be abolished or shortened considerably.

Monday night’s event didn’t end until around midnight.

The Post’s Adam Kilgore was on hand, and summed it all up perfectly by saying that Giancarlo Stanton’s moon shots were all that separated the event from being a complete and utter farce.

The damp Minnesota weather and the graveyard dimensions at Target Field reduced the annual Home Run Derby to a chore, a drag, calisthenics to be endured. Not even Yasiel Puig — neon sleeve down his right arm, star etched into his haircut, bat twirling in his right hand, ready to be flipped halfway to Lake Minnetonka — could enliven the bore. None of the pitches Robinson Cano’s dad, Jose, threw him cleared the fence. The zero on the scoreboard remained unchanged, and the lumber retired un-flipped.

The place yearned for energy, and then a man who looked like an outside linebacker crossed with a mountain lion stepped into the batter’s box. It was a Home Run Derby made to hate-watch, until it was redeemed by Giancarlo Cruz-Michael Stanton.

Keep in mind: Stanton didn’t win, and hit so many homers in the first round that he received a bye into the third round. “For the sake of what mattered, it meant less Giancarlo Stanton and more Not Giancarlo Stanton. That’s what you call a backfire,” Kilgore wrote. The event was one to be endured rather than enjoyed.

But hey, at least it wasn’t like the 1990 home run derby at Wrigley Field, when eight batters combined to hit only five home runs. It must have been gloriously brief.

After spending the first 17 years of his Post career writing and editing, Matt and the printed paper had an amicable divorce in 2014. He's now blogging and editing for the Early Lead and the Post's other Web-based products.
Comments
Show Comments
Most Read Sports
Stats, scores and schedules
Next Story
Des Bieler · July 15

Every story. Every feature. Every insight.

Yours for as low as JUST 99¢!

Not Now