Most Read: Politics

In The Loop
Posted at 01:07 PM ET, 06/28/2012

Chief Justice Roberts votes for Obama, who didn’t vote for him

Supreme Court Chief Justice John G. Roberts (Tim Sloan - AFP/Getty Images)
So, turns out Chief Justice John Roberts — the guy newly elected Sen. Barack Obama voted against confirming back in 2005 — was the key vote to rescue Obama’s signature health-care law.

Obama actually wanted to vote for Roberts, as Richard Wolffe recounts in his excellent book, “Renegade: The Making of a President,” but was talked out of it by his trusted adviser, Pete Rouse.

“You know,” he told his staff, “I would hope, if I’m president someday, twenty years down the road, Republicans will judge my nominees on the merits, whether they agree with them philosophically or not.”

Rouse, a Hill veteran who is now Obama’s deputy chief of staff, must have sighed when he responded.

“This isn’t Harvard Law School’s moot court,” he argued. “This is the political arena. If this guy is technically qualified and a brilliant legal mind, that’s fine. But in the real world, votes have consequences,” Wolffe wrote in 2010.

Rouse said Republicans 20 years later weren’t going “to vote for a Larry Tribe” because Obama had voted for Roberts. “That might be different,” Rouse said, “but that’s not going to happen,” Rouse explained to the new kid on the block.

“The reality is you’re going to have to live with the consequences of this vote 20 years from now and they’re not likely to be good,” Still, Obama castigated “progressives for their attacks on his fellow Democrats who voted for Roberts,” Wolffe wrote.

Good thing for Obama that Roberts got confirmed anyway. No telling if another chief would have broken with his fellow judges and conservative pundits — who have taken to calling him a “traitor to his philosophy” and mumbling about impeaching him.

Unclear if Obama has been giving Rouse grief about his prediction.

(Special Loop thanks to The Post’s fact-checker, Glenn Kessler, who actually remembered this passage.)

By  |  01:07 PM ET, 06/28/2012

Tags:  supreme court ruling, supreme court, richard wolffe, john roberts, obama and roberts, supreme court health care ruling, supreme court decision today, supreme court health care, supreme court ruling, individual mandate, health care upheld, supreme court rulings, individual mandate upheld, health care tax, obamacare, supreme court opinion, supreme court, scotus healthcare, aca, supreme court upholds health care, health care ruling, obamacare decision, healthcare decision, roberts supreme court, supreme court opinion, health care ruling, affordable care act, supreme court health, supreme court decision, health care reform, scotus obamacare, obamacare decision, Richard Wolffe, Al Kamen, Glenn Kessler, Emily Heil, In the Loop

Read what others are saying

    © 2011 The Washington Post Company