wpostServer: http://css.washingtonpost.com/wpost
ideas@innovations
About Dominic | About Vivek | About Emi | E-mail Us E-mail |  On Twitter Follow |  On Facebook Fan |  RSS RSS Feed
Posted at 06:00 AM ET, 09/01/2011

Should résumés replace school transcripts?


Should these students get grades or additional lines on their résumé?

We recently joined our colleagues @innovations on Tumblr. We’re pretty excited about it — especially by all of the new ideas and conversations we’re reading. But one idea stood out to us Wednesday: What if the traditional school transcript was replaced with a résumé?

The question was posed on the blog Cooperative Catalyst, in a post by Puget Sound Community School’s Steve Miranda. In the post, Miranda argues that transcripts fail to provide enough information about a student’s abilities to succeed outside of the classroom. While a transcript can tell you how well a student followed directions, a résumé, argues Miranda, could tell you how proactive, creative and truly accomplished a student is. Miranda writes:

If I’m hiring someone, what I really want to know is whether or not they’re going to add value to the organization. If all they can do is follow directions and blend in . . . well, there are plenty of people who can do that. How are you going to change the organization for the better? What possibilities can you show us that we never knew existed?

Dale Stephens, the leader of the uncollege movement, addressed the larger question this month of conventional schooling’s universal worth. He wrote:

Our education system cultivates a mind-set where students are rewarded for following directions. If we still needed public education to fulfill its original purpose — to train factory workers in the industrial revolution — then school would work brilliantly. But times have changed — a May 2010 IBM poll of CEOs found that they deemed creativity to be “the number one leadership competency of the successful enterprise of the future.”

So, what if schools did away with the traditional transcript. If CEO’s are citing creativity as the most important attribute of corporate leaders, then is it time we started ranking students like we would potential hires?

The question speaks to a fundamental aspect of schooling. As unemployment remains high, and the president and leading Republican presidential candidates prepare to unveil their jobs plans, it’s worth asking whether the preparation for future employment — not only in terms of education but presentation and mindset — should begin earlier, with students learning how to present themselves in the language of the working world well before they’re old enough to formally enter it.

— What do you think? Should the resume replace the traditional school transcript?

We’ve received a lot of great feedback from readers via Twitter. Here are some of your responses:

@washingtonpost @OnInnovations Transcripts should exist, but résumés are more valuable for providing insight about creativity & ambitionsFri Sep 02 11:30:47 via Twitter for BlackBerry®

No but should replace standrdzd tests! @washingtonpost Should résumés replace school transcripts? http://t.co/borjyyc via @OnInnovationsFri Sep 02 09:35:18 via Twitter for Android

No! Its a package deal RT @washingtonpost: Should résumés replace school transcripts? http://t.co/3PCwGdC via @OnInnovationsFri Sep 02 09:23:44 via UberSocial for BlackBerry

Absolutely not! They should be supplemental RT @washingtonpost Should résumés replace school transcripts? wapo.st/n7wGB2 via @OnInnovationsFri Sep 02 09:00:07 via web

(Cooperative Cataylst via Adventures in Learning)

By  |  06:00 AM ET, 09/01/2011

Categories:  Education, Morning Read

 
Read what others are saying
     

    © 2011 The Washington Post Company