Search

Ask Warren Brown

There are no discussions scheduled today.

Real Wheels Live

Real Wheels Live

The Post’s Warren Brown will be online to answer your questions about every aspect of the automotive industry.

Weekly schedule, past shows

Posted at 09:03 AM ET, 10/12/2013

Should I Buy an Audi Q7 or an Acura MDX?


(Cars.com)
"Should I buy an Audi Q7 or an Acura MDX?"

Anonymous

It would have been helpful if you had provided just a tad more information about yourself, such as the type of driving you do, whether you have kids, whether comfort is more important than performance or why you're considering these luxury SUVs.

That leaves us with so little to work with that we'll send the ball back to your side of the court with these suggestions:

The $43,185 MDX has been redesigned for 2014 and is quieter, more refined and more fuel-efficient (18/27 mpg city/highway with optional all-wheel drive) than the previous generation, which had more attitude and was more performance-oriented.

The $48,595 Q7 is more driver-oriented than most luxury SUVs, but the current model debuted for the 2007 model year — ancient history in the auto industry. A redesigned Q7 is expected in the U.S. in 2015, and it should be considerably lighter than the current model's 5,567 pounds (versus 4,255 pounds for an all-wheel-drive 2014 MDX). The all-wheel-drive MDX's mileage is almost as good as the Q7 TDI diesel with standard all-wheel drive, which is the more efficient option of the available engines at 19/28 mpg. Compare other MDX and Q7 specifications here .

If you're concerned about reliability, Acura has finished above the industry average in the last three J.D. Power and Associates Vehicle Dependability Studies, which measure problems in the third year of ownership. Audi has been below the industry average in those three years. Acura was eighth among 32 brands in the most recent study, and Audi was 23rd.

Related

By Cars.com  |  09:03 AM ET, 10/12/2013

 
Read what others are saying
     

    © 2011 The Washington Post Company