Who is responsible for the District’s $50 million estate tax haul?

January 30, 2013
Evelyn Nef was a famed philanthropist. But she wasn’t the District’s $50 million “whale.” (Sarah L. Voisin — The Washington Post)

This post has been updated.

There was no more tantalizing detail in Tuesday’s rollout of the city’s annual financial audit than this: One dead taxpayer is apparently responsible for a $50 million contribution to city coffers — helping to pump estate tax collections $53 million over projections and contributing mightily to an overall surplus of $417 million.

So who was — to borrow a term from the Las Vegas casinos — this “whale”?

City tax officials are keeping a tight lid on the person’s identity, given the nasty penalties for improperly disclosing a taxpayer’s private information. So that leaves us to a rather fun game of parlor speculation.

One name openly floated has been Evelyn Nef, a Georgetown arts patron who died in 2009. At Tuesday’s Q&A Cafe event with Mayor Vincent C. Gray, journalist Carol Joynt mentioned Nef’s name, and a few other folks mentioned it to me Tuesday as a possibility.

But lawyer Michael F. Curtin, who handled Nef’s estate, all but laughed at me when I suggested Nef might have been responsible for the $50 million haul. “A categorical no,” he said.

Curtin, a prominent probate lawyer in town, said it’s hard to fathom such a huge estate tax payout to the city. “It would be a very unusual estate that would be paying $50 million to the District for state estate tax,” he said.

Most people of those means, he suggested, would have tax strategies in place to avoid having to make a payment of that size. (Only D.C. and 16 states have a local estate tax.) Then again, he said, “There are some people who don’t mind paying the taxes. But I don’t know a lot of those kind of people.”

There are some clues to the whale’s species. The District’s estate tax is 16 percent, meaning the deceased would have had a taxable estate of more than $300 million. Also, Curtin said, estate tax is due in almost all cases 10 months after death — meaning the person likely died in August 2011 or thereafter.

One newsworthy death in August 2011 was Viola Drath, the 91-year old Georgetown woman allegedly murdered by husband Albrecht Muth. But there is no indication Drath has anywhere near the sort of wealth that would result in a $50 million estate tax payout.

Over at the Washington Business Journal, reporter Michael Neibauer tossed out a couple of names last year: billionaire developer and sports owner Abe Pollin, and heiress and philanthropist Isabelle Scott. Both died too early; Pollin, furthermore, was a Maryland resident and was survived by his wife, Irene, who would have inherited the estate tax-free.

Any guesses?

Update, 4:05 p.m.: Neibauer has another guess, and it’s a good one: Sidney Harman, the electronics magnate and philanthropist, who died here in April 2011. His net worth, at $500 million, is in the ballpark for a $50 million estate tax payout. And, as an outspoken Democrat, he might just have been one of those people who don’t mind paying taxes.

I’ve sent a note to his widow, former congresswoman Jane Harman, seeking comment.

Updated, 12:45 a.m.: Credit where credit is due — two observers also guessed Harman before Neibauer published his item: Commenter tcfenstermaker and Tweeter Marie Drissel. And I still haven’t heard back from Jane Harman.

Updated, Jan. 31, 10:45 a.m.: Peter Reid, a spokesman for the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars — where Jane Harman is director and CEO — said Thursday, “The speculation is incorrect.”

Mike DeBonis covers Congress and national politics for The Washington Post. He previously covered D.C. politics and government from 2007 to 2015.
Continue reading
Comments
Show Comments
Most Read Local