Ben Nelson retirement: How does it affect the Senate landscape?
Nebraska Sen. Ben Nelson’s (D) decision to leave the Senate in 2012 clearly makes it more difficult for his party to hold his seat but may not have that large an impact on the national Senate playing field.
Here’s why.
Nebraska was always going to be a very tough race for Democrats. While Nelson won races in 2000 and 2006, the state’s clear Republican lean — President Obama won just 42 percent in the state in 2008 — made the race a decided longshot even with a proven commodity like Nelson in the race.
“He’ll be missed as a vote for [Harry] Reid for leader, but he had a very, very hard race against tough odds,” said Jim Jordan, a former executive director at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and now a party consultant.
(With Nelson gone, the race verges on unwinnable for Democrats — although party strategists insist that former Sen. Bob Kerrey, who has spent the better part of the last decade as president of the New School in New York City, is genuinely interested in running. Reached Tuesday in India, Kerrey didn’t address his own interest but said that Nelson’s retirement was “a big loss for Nebraska”.)
In truth, many Republicans already taken to counting Nebraska in their “win” column along with the open seat in North Dakota. (Democrats dispute the idea that the North Dakota open seat won’t be competitive but, like Nebraska, the state’s decided GOP tilt makes it tough sledding.)
While Nelson bowing out strengthens Republicans’ chances in Nebraska then, it doesn’t fundamentally alter the underlying math for GOPers to win back control of the Senate.
Give Republicans Nebraska and North Dakota and they are one seat short of the majority if the GOP nominee ousts President Obama next November. Republicans need to net two seats short if Obama is re-elected to a second term.
The majority still will come down to a handful of seats — Missouri, Montana, Virginia, Florida, Ohio — that both parties acknowledge are likely to be very, very close. Democrats now have marginally less margin for error but, in truth, they never had much room to slip if they want to stay in control of the Senate in 2013.
“It’s a big loss but control of the Senate is not as controlled by the map as many think,” said Steve Murphy, a veteran Democratic consultant, of the Nelson retirement “If Obama is re-elected, and I think he will be, Democrats will hold the Senate.”
That doesn’t mean, however, that Nelson’s retirement doesn’t have any impact on the national landscape.
The biggest ripple effect it will have is financially where national Republicans would have had to spend heavily to pry Nelson out of the seat. While a Kerrey candidacy might make the race competitive, if he decides not to run it’s very likely that both parties will simply write the race off — ala North Dakota in 2010. (Of course, you could also make the counter argument that Nelson’s retirement will allow Senate Democrats to stop throwing good money after bad.)
Outside of Nebraska, the Nelson retirement should help Senate Republicans raise money — particularly in the near-term as it will drive chatter about their prospects of taking control of the majority. Momentum matters when it comes to raising money and Republicans will — and should — paint the Nelson retirement as a sign that they are now fully on offense.
To be clear: The Nelson retirement isn’t good news for Senate Democrats. But it is far from a death blow to their hopes of retaining the majority either.
Sen. Ben Nelson won't seek reelection
- Spam
- Obscene
- Duplicate
Blog Contributors
Chris Cillizza

Chris Cillizza is founder and editor of The Fix, a leading blog on state and national politics. He is the author of The Gospel According to the Fix: An Insider’s Guide to a Less than Holy World of Politics and an MSNBC contributor and political analyst. He also regularly appears on NBC and NPR’s The Diane Rehm Show. He joined The Post in 2005 and was named one of the top 50 journalists by Washingtonian in 2009.
Juliet Eilperin

Juliet Eilperin covers the White House for the Washington Post. She served as the Post's House of Representatives reporter from 1998-2004, covering the impeachment of Bill Clinton, lobbying, legislation, and five national congressional campaigns. Since 2004 she has been one of the country’s leading reporters covering the environment, reporting on science, policy and politics in areas including climate change, oceans, and air quality. She is the author of two books, "Fight Club Politics: How Partisanship is Poisoning the House of Representatives," and "Demon Fish: Travels Through the Hidden World of Sharks." Follow her on Twitter.
Ed O’Keefe

Ed O’Keefe covers Congress and politics for the Washington Post. He previously covered the 2008 and 2012 campaigns and reported on federal agencies and federal employees as author of The Federal Eye blog. Follow Ed on Twitter.
Aaron Blake

Aaron Blake covers national politics at the Washington Post, where he writes regularly for “The Fix,” the Post’s top political blog. A Minnesota native and summa cum laude graduate of the University of Minnesota, Aaron has also written about politics for the Minneapolis Star-Tribune and The Hill newspaper. Aaron and his wife, Danielle, live in Annandale, Va. Follow him on Twitter.
Sean Sullivan

Sean Sullivan covers national politics for “The Fix.” Prior to joining the Washington Post in the summer of 2012, Sean was the editor of Hotline On Call, National Journal Hotline’s politics blog. He has also worked for NHK Japan Public Broadcasting and ABC News. Sean is a graduate of Hamilton College, where he received a degree in Philosophy. He lives in Washington, D.C. Follow Sean on Twitter.
Scott Clement

Scott Clement is a survey research analyst for Capital Insight, the independent polling group of Washington Post Media. Scott specializes in public opinion about politics, election campaigns and public policy. He helps design and analyze all Washington Post polls, including the Washington Post-ABC News poll. Follow Scott on Twitter.
Rachel Weiner

Rachel Weiner covers national politics for Post Politics and The Fix. She came to the Washington Post in 2010 as a political web editor and anchored the Post's 2012 election blog. She was previously a web editor at The Huffington Post. Follow her on Twitter.











Loading...
Comments