Libertarianism might be all the rage, but its adherents might not be as "libertarian" as you think.
That's the premise of a very interesting new Pew Research Center piece, which notes that there are relatively few big differences between how those who call themselves libertarians and everybody else view the role of government regulation, foreign policy and personal liberty.
Here are the most striking figures (while encouraging you to read the whole piece):
No. 2 shows an approximation of New York's "stop and frisk" policy is the biggest red flag here. The idea that 4 in 10 real, genuine libertarians support such a policy in basically equal numbers as the general populace just doesn't really pass muster.
Neither does the idea that libertarians would push for a more active U.S. role in foreign affairs than the rest of Americans, as No. 1 shows.
Yes, there are certainly libertarians of all shapes and sizes, with varying degrees of belief in the role of government. But on the whole, being libertarian means erring on the side of individual liberty over government regulation and expansion. On all of these measures, libertarians as a whole are pretty much tucked nicely inside the political mainstream -- so much so that they almost look like political moderates.
So is that because people don't know what being a libertarian is, or is it because being a libertarian doesn't mean what it used to?
Pew tried to control for the former, asking people to correctly identify the over-arching libertarian philosophy. While 14 percent of people claimed to be libertarians, included in the numbers above are only the 11 percent who knew what that actually meant.
We would argue, though, that many within that 11 percent still don't really know what it means.