Tomorrow's decision is all about the president

This moment of anticipation around tomorrow’s Supreme Court decision reminds me of periods from previous momentous decisions: the Nixon tapes and Bush v. Gore. There are many theories of what and why the court will decide, often conflicting. (For a really helpful guide to how to read and begin to interpret tomorrow’s decision check this out. There is much speculation about the political consequences;  it too, is divided.

You can read much better discussions of the potential policy scenarios depending on the court’s decision here:

National Journal:Urgent Business

Washington Post: Ruling likely to have long-term fallout

Politico: For health industry, ‘every man for himself’

But it is the politics that is our topic.

I will have more to say tomorrow when the decision is rendered, but, politically, I think this will all be about perceptions of the president. If the law is upheld, Obama will be somewhat stronger.  If parts of the law are struck down — the mandate most obviously — then Obama will be much weaker; it will weaken further perceptions of his effectiveness as a leader. I will have more to say later about how the political nuances of the decision might impact voter turn-out within the respective party bases, or how it might alter messaging. But my initial read is this: If the Nixon tapes case was all about the re-balance of constructional power between the three branches of government, and Bush v. Gore was all about the politicization of the Supreme Court, tomorrow’s decision is all about the president.


Success! Check your inbox for details. You might also like:

Please enter a valid email address

See all newsletters

Show Comments
Most Read


Success! Check your inbox for details.

See all newsletters