The irony behind Britain’s new Mahatma Gandhi statue

A statue of Mahatma Gandhi was unveiled in London's Parliament Square on Saturday, to mark the 100th anniversary of his return to India from South Africa to begin the country's journey to independence from British rule. It will stand alongside other historic figures in the square including Winston Churchill, Nelson Mandela and Abraham Lincoln. (YouTube/Conservatives)

The British government prepared to unveil a new statue of Indian independence icon Mahatma Gandhi opposite Parliament on Saturday. Gandhi will take his place alongside statues of other pioneering statesmen, including Nelson Mandela and Abraham Lincoln. Gandhi will be the only figure represented there who never once held political office.

The statue's unveiling marks the centennial of Gandhi's return to India from South Africa, where the then-young lawyer had begun cultivating his ideas about self-rule and civil disobedience.

"As the father of the largest democracy in the world, it’s time for Gandhi to take his place in front of the mother of Parliament," said Britain's chancellor of the exchequer, George Osborne, when the plans were first announced last year. "He is a figure of inspiration, not just in Britain and India, but around the world."

That's certainly true. Gandhi statues have proliferated all over the world, from his homeland to New York City's Union Square and many parks and squares in between.

But there's an undeniable irony in placing a statue of Gandhi before an institution he struggled against for decades.

India's parliamentary democracy may draw directly from the Westminster model — Osborne's "mother of Parliament" — but that is hardly a political system Gandhi considered ideal. His vision for Indian democracy involved something built from the country's myriad villages, a decentralized, grass-roots politics that drew its power from the freedom of every individual, not the monuments and gilded halls of the capital. It was a worldview that was as spiritual as it was political. And it certainly didn't owe a debt to the British Parliament, the Magna Carta or any other founding institution of Britain's own democracy.

The new Gandhi statue comes at a time when Britain is seeking to improve trade and economic ties with India and the recently elected government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. But that eagerness to deepen links with India — as well as pander to voters of Indian origin at home — constantly rubs against debates about the injustices of Britain's imperial past.

In recent years, British Prime Minister David Cameron has had to tip-toe awkwardly around the long-standing Indian demand for the return of the Koh-i-Noor diamond, captured in 1850 and eventually fitted into the queen mother's crown that's on display in the Tower of London.

In 2013, Cameron made a non-apology during a visit to the northern Indian city of Amritsar, where hundreds of Indian protesters were fatally shot by British troops in 1919.

The incident was memorialized in the 1982 Oscar-winning film "Gandhi," but Cameron did not formally apologize for the massacre, only describing it as a "deeply shameful event."

On one hand, this is understandable. If Britain's prime minister formally apologized for one slaughter in one corner of its lapsed empire, there would be demands for similar overtures for atrocities elsewhere. Given the scale of the British empire — and how much blood it arguably has on its hands — that would warrant a seemingly endless, probably untenable apology tour on the part of the British premier.

But it would be fitting if the presence of Gandhi's gaunt figure outside the halls of Westminster served as a permanent reminder of Britain's darker legacy.

This article was originally published last year, when news of the planned statue was first announced. It has been updated.

Related link: The dark side of Winston Churchill no one should forget

Ishaan Tharoor writes about foreign affairs for The Washington Post. He previously was a senior editor at TIME, based first in Hong Kong and later in New York.

world

worldviews

Success! Check your inbox for details. You might also like:

Please enter a valid email address

See all newsletters

Comments
Show Comments
Most Read World

world

worldviews

Success! Check your inbox for details.

See all newsletters

Next Story
Ishaan Tharoor · March 13