Wells Fargo, Justice Department settle discrimination case for $175 million

Justin Sullivan/GETTY IMAGES - DALY CITY, CA - JULY 12: Customers use ATMs at a Wells Fargo Bank branch office on July 12, 2012 in Daly City, California. The Justice Department announced Thursday that Wells Fargo Bank, the largest residential home mortgage originator in the United States, will pay nearly $175 million to settle accusations of discrimination against qualified African-American and Hispanic borrowers between 2004 and 2009. The alleged discrimination is in violation of fair-lending laws. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Of the 34,000 minorities that Justice said were subjected to discrimination, 4,000 were improperly steered into subprime loans. It estimates they will receive an average of $15,000 each under the settlement.

The problem, Justice found, was that brokers could earn more money making subprime loans than by originating prime mortgages. The company capped compensation at 4.5 percent of a prime loan, while the cap for subprime mortgages was 5 percent. That translated into a $1,500 difference for an average loan of $300,000 and created an incentive for brokers to originate as many subprime loans as possible.

Gallery

More business news

Why bullies succeed at work

Why bullies succeed at work

We've all wished the line between what some people call bullying and what others call strong leadership wasn't so fuzzy.

Chinese hackers gained access to surveillance data, U.S. officials say

Chinese hackers gained access to surveillance data, U.S. officials say

Hackers who breached Google database may have sought identities of Chinese spies in U.S.

Seamless and GrubHub to combine, terms not disclosed

Seamless and GrubHub to combine, terms not disclosed

Rival online takeout services Seamless and GrubHub announce plans to create a new company covering more than 20,000 restaurants.

More business news

Wells Fargo tried to address the issue by creating a filter intended to identify prime customers. But according to Justice, brokers easily bypassed the process by encouraging borrowers to skip the down payment or withhold certain documents — steps disqualifying them for a prime loan. Often borrowers were not told that they were eligible for a better interest rate.

Federal investigators said senior Wells Fargo officials knew about those practices but did little to stop them.

In addition, even when black and Hispanic customers got prime loans, they paid higher fees than white borrowers, Justice alleged. The average African American taking out a $300,000 prime loan was charged $2,064 more in broker fees than a similarly qualified white customer. Latino borrowers paid an average of $1,251 more.

“The department’s action makes clear that we will hold financial institutions accountable, including some of the nation’s largest, for lending discrimination,” Deputy Attorney General James M. Cole said.

Wells Fargo said Thursday that it will no longer work with independent mortgage brokers, which originate about 5 percent of its loan volume.

As part of the settlement, it is also reviewing subprime mortgages made by in-house loan officers to determine whether any black or Latino borrowers may have qualified for prime mortgages instead. The compensation for those customers would be added to the $175 million settlement.

Justice estimated that identifying and distributing the payments to consumers would take about a year. But it also acknowledged that the long-term consequences to minority communities could take far longer to repair.

The Washington Post reported this week that a growing chorus of consumer advocates, economists and civil rights leaders are raising concerns that the fallout from the boom in subprime lending has endangered the financial futures of black Americans by lowering their credit scores.

“The impacts of lending discrimination and the harm to a person’s credit can be far reaching — inhibiting a range of opportunities that affect a person’s ability to find housing, good employment or access higher education,” said Perez, the assistant attorney general.

The Wells Fargo agreement comes less than two months after Justice negotiated a $21 million settlement with SunTrust Mortgage over similar allegations. Last year, it reached a $335 million agreement with Countrywide Financial, now owned by Bank of America, in what is the largest fair-lending settlement in the department’s history.

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges