Keystone XL pipeline would add link in U.S.-Canada trade relations

At the remote border crossing north of here, two stern U.S. border guards emerged from their spanking new post to check passports. There wasn’t another person or car in sight. An uninterrupted sea of prairie stretched in every direction.

On the Canadian side, the nearest town is Val Marie, the entrance to Grasslands National Park and home to 137 people. On the U.S. side, it’s Loring, population nine — not counting the dog called mayor.

Map: Keystone XL pipeline

Explore the controversies surrounding the pipeline. View the full graphic

Video

Keystone: Leaving Canada

4,000 angus cattle, 3,000 acres of farm land, and nine people: Kenny Clark, a resident of Loring, Mont., talks about life in and near his sparsely populated town and shares what he thinks of the proposed expansion of the Keystone pipeline.

More on this series

Canadian town gears up for pipeline

Canadian town gears up for pipeline

In Hardisty, TransCanada is adding oil storage, building oil-measuring and -testing facilities and running pipefor the Keystone XL.

The Bakken billionaire’s oil optimism

The Bakken billionaire’s oil optimism

Harold Hamm made billions on the Bakken oil boom and now he is using his wealth in GOP politics.

About the series

About the series

Three journalists traveled the proposed pipeline route. Learn more about their journey.

More on this Story

View all Items in this Story

“The border is 16 miles away, and in between, there are 4,000 Angus cattle and 3,000 acres of farmland and that’s about it,” said Kenny Clark, a mechanic and oil worker who lives in Loring with his wife, two children and parents.

Soon, there might be one more thing: TransCanada’s Keystone XL pipeline. The company wants to run its controversial new pipeline not far from this outpost.

In its May 4 application to the U.S. State Department for a permit to cross an international boundary, TransCanada said it would run a 1.2-mile segment of steel pipe into Phillips County, Mont., traversing the first 0.93 mile on Bureau of Land Management land and the next 0.27 mile on state land.

If the U.S. government gives TransCanada the go ahead, the Keystone XL pipeline will give another boost to U.S.-Canada trade relations. Canada — not China — is the largest U.S. trading partner. And oil and gas accounted for more than a third of the $316.5 billion of U.S. imports from Canada in 2011.

The oil in TransCanada’s existing Keystone and proposed Keystone XL lines alone could outstrip the value of all U.S. imports from Brazil and, depending on the price, roughly equal those from France or Taiwan.

The United States is a natural destination for that oil. “The best market is the one right next to us demanding 10 million barrels of oil every day,” TransCanada chief executive Russ Girling said. “It makes no sense having tankers moving to the U.S. from Europe and the Middle East and tankers going to Asia from America.”

The large volume of oil moving to the United States from Canada is a good thing in the eyes of many U.S. experts on national security and oil industry lobbyists, who have been promoting the idea of increased U.S. reliance on North American sources of oil rather than on imports from places like Venezuela or Saudi Arabia. Canada is already the United States’ largest source of foreign petroleum, accounting for about a quarter of U.S. crude oil imports.

But reduced reliance on imports from outside North America would not insulate the United States from geopolitical crises in other oil-producing regions. When it comes to oil prices, the increased reliance on Canada will make little or no difference. The price of crude oil is a function of world supply and demand. And if a geopolitical crisis choked off some of the world’s oil sources, other consuming countries would scramble for supplies, and prices would soar globally, including the price of Canadian oil. The U.S. tab for importing oil would increase as a result.

Even so, many trade experts say, boosting U.S. imports from Canada is good for the U.S. economy because for every dollar of exports to the United States, Canada buys 85 cents’ worth of U.S.-made products. That includes goods such as U.S. iron and steel, automobiles, refined petroleum products, fruits and juices, plastics and the supersized Caterpillar dump trucks that haul away oil extracted from the tar sands of Alberta.

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges