Lawmakers, advocates push social networks for more protection of youngest users

Silly Bandz and Pokeman cards need to make room for another craze hitting the monkey bars crowd: Facebook.

Young children are flocking to social networking Web sites that had been the domain of smart phone-toting high-schoolers and young adults.

Video

June 7 (Bloomberg) -- Scott Galloway, founder of L2 Think Tank and a professor at New York University, talks about the outlook for companies' use of Facebook.

June 7 (Bloomberg) -- Scott Galloway, founder of L2 Think Tank and a professor at New York University, talks about the outlook for companies' use of Facebook.

Gallery

More on this Story

View all Items in this Story

About 5 million U.S. users on Facebook are younger than 10 and 2.5 million subscribers are 11 or 12 years old, according to a recent survey by Consumer Reports magazine.

And the youngest of Web users aren’t just on Facebook. They are logging onto social networks such as Formspring, tweeting their location to the Web, and making friends out of strangers on Disney and other games sites.

That’s a lot of freedom on the Internet for children who can’t ride in the front seat of a car or leave school with a friend without a signed permission slip from Mom or Dad.

Maybe too much freedom, in the opinion of child advocates and lawmakers, who are pressuring companies to work harder to keep the youngest users offline and to create federal rules that would limit how companies collect information about children on the Internet.

California is deliberating a bill that would give parents the right to demand that social networking sites such as Facebook delete addresses, e-mail accounts and other personally identifiable information about a youth if a parent asks. Facebook, Google and Twitter have launched an assault against the legislation, saying it squashes free expression.

U.S. Reps. Ed J. Markey (D-Mass.) and Joe Barton (R-Tex.) have proposed a bill that would make it harder for children to be tracked online and limit marketers from gathering information on a teen’s whereabouts and personal information.

“Companies have had their chance and they haven’t done enough. Kids can be targeted by scammers, cyber-bullies and marketers and the companies aren’t doing enough to protect them,” said Jim Steyer, president of child advocacy group Common Sense Media.

He and lawmakers such as Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) argue that the great technological minds of Silicon Valley ought to be able to do a better job of verifying the ages of their customers.

Facebook says that’s not so easy.

It sets a minimum age of 13 and purges the accounts of users found to be in violation. Google, Foursquare, Formspring and other social networking sites set the same age limit. But they argue that there is little they can do if a user who was born in 2001 puts in a birth date of 1970. Verifying age raises a tangle of privacy issues for companies, who aren’t able to use personal information about young users in the first place, experts say.

Facebook says it’s using technology to patrol for offensive content and working with law enforcement to catch child predators. It regularly purges accounts of underage users, but it declined to say how many sites are deleted each day.

“Recent reports have highlighted just how difficult it is to implement age restrictions on the Internet and that there is no single solution to ensuring younger children don’t circumvent a system or lie about their age,” Facebook spokesman Andrew Noyes said.

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment

The Washington Post commenting system will be disabled for several hours while system upgrades are made. User will be unable to leave comments during this time.

If you have any problems accessing Washington Post content during this time, please email our Interactivity department at comments@washpost.com.

 
Read what others are saying About Badges