Ron Charles
Ron Charles
Critic

Books: ‘Once Upon a River’ by Bonnie Jo Campbell

Tough as this young woman is, her survival is never guaranteed as she falls in with men who love her and men who abuse her. (And yes, they’re sometimes the same men.) You can’t help but share Margo’s raw hope each time she moves on, a little more wary, trying to figure out how to live. “She would count on no one to help or protect her,” Margo thinks, but wise as that decision may be — and it’s confirmed by her horrible experiences — it’s ultimately too lonely. In one of her darkest moments, she realizes that she had “let herself become a person who was no longer connected to other people.” Back on the water after another betrayal, “she climbed onto the boat’s back seat beside her rifle and curled there and thought about how nice it was to float, to let the river guide her.”

Margo may be paddling in the wake of Natty Bumppo, Huck Finn and Henry David Thoreau, but unlike those asexual heroes of the American wilderness, she’s a sexually active woman, which complicates our myth of the rugged woodsman considerably. It’s not long on her journey before “Margo had the feeling that her newly shaped body had a power that she needed to keep secret.” This is, after all, a story predicated on sexual violence, and when she can, Margo strikes back at one of her assailants in a singularly appropriate way. But what place is there — even in the wilds of Michigan — for a young woman who dares to live on her own and enjoy her own body? “Was it her worn jeans that made the woman call her freak?” Margo wonders. “Her worn Carhartt jacket? Was it her dark, heavy rowboat with its splintery oars? Or her gun visible on the back seat? Or was she a freak, plain and simple, a wolf girl, an aberration?”

More from Ron Charles

Ron came to The Post in 2005 from the Christian Science Monitor, where he was the Book Editor and lead critic. He lives in Bethesda with his wife, an English teacher at Bethesda-Chevy Chase High School.

Archive

Looking for things to do?
Select one or more criteria to search
Get ideas

In a hundred different ways, Margo hears that she’s not right, that she’s not acceptable, that her experience on the river can’t last. A Native American man who sleeps with her tells her, “You can’t get ahead in this life if you don’t finish school,” but Margo cuts right to the problem: “I don’t want to get ahead. What’s so great about getting ahead?”

For many chapters this is a sad, harrowing story, but Campbell doesn’t leave us there. Margo’s hushed voice is so pure, her spirit so indomitable, that you’ll yearn for her to find the freedom she craves, along with a stretch of clean water. “Once Upon a River” makes you realize with a stab of regret just how cramped and homogeneous our lives and our expectations of others are. I hope Margo’s out there somewhere skinning a catfish and cooking it on a hickory stick. It’s a hard life, to be sure, but this novel is a celebration of that possibility and its brutal costs.

Charles is The Post’s fiction editor. You can follow him on Twitter @RonCharles.

once upon a river

By Bonnie Jo Campbell

Norton. 348 pp. $25.95

More books content

Show Me:
Show more

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges