Review of ‘Care and Management of Lies’: In the trenches of the human spirit at wartime

July 20

Unlike the books in Jacqueline Winspear’s popular Maisie Dobbs series, The Care and Management of Lies” is not a mystery — although its scenes of World War I trench warfare certainly leave a reader in suspense. As much a story of the home front as of the battlefield, this new stand-alone novel is, above all, a moving tale about the beauty of those very virtues — fortitude, faithfulness, compassion — that the Great War called into question.

Winspear’s unusual title alludes to the language of a (fictional) domestic management book that our heroine, Kezia Marchant, receives from her best friend, Thea Brissenden, on the occasion of her wedding, in 1914. Kezia and Thea are both teachers, proud of their independence. Indeed, Thea has even begun to risk arrest by assuming an activist role in both the British women’s suffrage and pacifist movements. Kezia, a vicar’s daughter, has wed Thea’s brother, Tom, who runs the family farm in the Kentish countryside. As a passive-aggressive criticism of Kezia’s decision to take up the traditional life of a farm wife, Thea presents her with “The Woman’s Book,” a guide to basic chores like straining pudding and blacking the stove; in short, “Everything a Woman Ought to Know.”

It turns out that Kezia soon has reason to desperately consult this housewifery guide. Shortly after war is declared, Tom, like the other able-bodied men in the village, decides that it’s his patriotic duty to volunteer for service. When he is sent off to France, dainty Kezia must assume command of the few farmhands left behind, as well as of the horses, laundry wringer, orchards and hops fields. In credible and often comical detail, Winspear renders Kezia’s transformation from the city mouse to the country mouse that roared. Within months, she’s become adept at twisting the necks of chickens and pulling out their innards, just as Tom must become hardened to seeing the bloody intestines of his fellow infantrymen spill out of gaping wounds.

The worlds of the farm and the trenches are connected via the vivid letters that Kezia exchanges with both Tom and, less frequently, Thea (who’s become an ambulance driver in France). Tom’s accounts are terse; Kezia, however, serves up mouthwatering descriptions of meals she’s cooking for Tom (in her imagination, of course), and Tom soon finds himself sharing her culinary epistles with his fellow hungry soldiers. Here he is reading aloud Kezia’s description of making a gravy for baked wood pigeon:

“As you know, Tom, I don’t really care for a plain sauce. . . . I’d put up a good half-dozen jars of black currants in the summer, and I thought the color of them and their sweetish tart taste would do well with the bird, so here’s what I did. I simmered the pigeon flesh with some best butter. . . .


“The Care and Management of Lies” by Jacqueline Winspear. (Harper)

“ ‘I don’t know where your missus gets her ideas from. Mine would never think up something like that.’

“ ‘Ssshhh! Let ’im get on with the story.’ ”

Winspear writes with such authority and empathy that readers can’t help but feel that such homey scenes must have taken place in the trenches. By the time the story darkens into tragedy, we accept that those moments must have happened, too. “The Care and Management of Lies” is a quietly powerful story that more than holds its own in a publishing season crowded with novels and nonfiction commemorating the 100th anniversary of the start of World War I.

Corrigan, who is the book critic for the NPR program “Fresh Air,” teaches literature at Georgetown University.

THE CARE AND MANAGEMENT OF LIES

A Novel of the Great War

By Jacqueline Winspear

Harper. 319 pp. $26.99

Comments
Show Comments
Most Read Entertainment