Ann Hornaday
Ann Hornaday
Critic

Essay: Of manners, movies and the sorry state of spectatorship

‘The Tree of Life,’ left, caused one theater to post a memo warning about the film’s complex structure, after movie-goers demanded refunds. D.C.’s Avalon Theatre, top right, has surrendered to those who text while watching. ‘The Artist,’ bottom right, has drawn complaints from patrons who didn’t realize it was silent.

Last summer, denizens of the movie-watching world were abuzz over two cases of mortifying behavior in theaters: In Austin, the Alamo Drafthouse Cinema ejected an audience member for texting during a movie, in accordance with its rules. A few hours later, the angry young woman left a rambling, profane message on the theater’s voice-mail system (which Alamo owner Tim League promptly repurposed into an equally profane and utterly hilarious anti-texting trailer).

Shortly thereafter, the manager of the Avon Theatre in Stamford, Conn., was compelled to post a memo to his patrons reminding them that Terrence Malick’s “The Tree of Life” — an ambitious, discursive, occasionally confounding meditation on everything from the creation of the universe to patriarchal family dynamics in 1950s America — was, indeed, an ambitious, discursive, occasionally confounding meditation on everything from the creation of the universe to patriarchal family dynamics in 1950s America.

(Mikey Burton/ For The Washington Post ) - New rules for the modern film-goer — Rule No. 1:Turn off your phone. That means texting, too. Seriously.
  • (Mikey Burton/ For The Washington Post ) - New rules for the modern film-goer — Rule No. 1:Turn off your phone. That means texting, too. Seriously.
  • (Mikey Burton/ For The Washington Post ) - New rules for the modern film-goer — Rule No. 2: It’s okay to expand your horizons every once in a while.
  • (Mikey Burton/ For The Washington Post ) - New rules for the modern film-goer — Rule No. 3: Don’t ask for a refund if the movie wasn’t what you expected.
  • (Mikey Burton/ For The Washington Post ) - New rules for the modern film-goer — Rule No. 4: There may be nudity. A man may be sawing his arm of. You were warned.

(Mikey Burton/ For The Washington Post ) - New rules for the modern film-goer — Rule No. 1:Turn off your phone. That means texting, too. Seriously.

Gallery

Looking for things to do?
Select one or more criteria to search
Get ideas

“We would like to remind patrons that ‘The Tree of Life’ is a uniquely visionary and deeply philosophical film by an auteur director,” the memo read, before understating, “It does not follow a traditional, linear narrative approach to storytelling.” The note concluded by announcing that the theater would not be handing out refunds to disgruntled audience members — a policy they needed to reinforce after a few filmgoers walked out on the film and demanded their money back. “The Avon stands behind this ambitious work of art and other challenging films, which define us as a true art house cinema,” the memo concluded, “and we hope you will expand your horizons with us.”

Expanding their horizons? What a quaint idea. More and more, it seems, that’s the last thing filmgoers are interested in doing. Powered by fandom’s technologically amplified voice, they instead prefer cinematic experiences that simply confirm their own assumptions of what a cinematic experience should be.

Through such outlets as Facebook, Twitter and the comment sections of sites such as Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic, the notion that “everyone’s a critic” has never been truer. Or scarier. Because with that exciting new empowerment has come an unwelcome petulant edge. A sense of ad­ven­ture has been replaced, in some quarters, by a sense of entitlement.

If 2011 was the year of Angry Voters and Angry Birds, it was also the year of the Angry Moviegoers.

The months since the “The Tree of Life” memo have brought fresh outrages, from the woman who sued the company that released “Drive” because it didn’t contain enough driving, to the British filmgoers who recently demanded refunds when they realized that “The Artist” was a silent movie (no word on whether they contacted their lawyers when they saw that it was in black and white).

Dear filmgoers, as a critic, I cast myself as your advocate in the multiplex. I try — with limited success, judging from a couple of recent e-mails about “The Grey” — to shine a light on deserving gems, warn you off the dreck and somehow anticipate the individual tastes and desires of an audience that spans generations, genders, ethnicities, religious creeds and constitutional tolerance of sex, violence and Adam Sandler comedies.

More movies content

Show Me:
Show more

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges