“Why wouldn’t I be cast as that person?” Payton asks simply, ticking off the kinds of obstacles that get brought up (race, body type, alto parts such as Motormouth Maybelle that are not strictly suited to her soprano voice). “If I can sing it and I can act it, I should be able to be cast in it. . . . I always thought that if you go in and you audition for a show, in their mind you may not be the person, but your audition can change the whole look of it. So that kind of was a turnoff.”
After leaving school, a brief gig in something called “Acoustic Chocolate” at the newly refurbished Hippodrome in Baltimore was followed by the bus-and-truck tour of “Smokey Joe’s Cafe.” She was 24 and had been married for two years to her high school sweetheart.
“I think the tour took a toll on that, though,” Payton says of her first marriage, which dissolved after three years.
Payton tells a story of how a friend’s agent helped her get an audition for the role of Effie in Philadelphia, even though he had never heard her sing. The callbacks seemed endless, and Payton recalls finally getting to perform for musical director Jesse Vargas.
“He was like, ‘I don’t understand why y’all are putting her through all this,’ ” she says. “ ‘This girl can sing. What are you all doing?’ ”
The show was an extended hit and got Payton her Actors’ Equity card, which led her to . . . another “Smokey Joe’s Cafe,” this time for the Flat Rock Playhouse in North Carolina. Resettling in the District, Payton worked with Adventure Theatre and Washington Savoyards before grabbing attention at a Signature audition two years ago.
It took the company a while to know what to do with her, and if “Dreamgirls” makes it look as though the talented Payton is running in place, she doesn’t see it that way. The show means a lot to her, and she says she relates to its drama: She has lived the girl-group stuff and survived disappointments with men.
“I’m in a different place,” Payton says. She has a 3-year-old son by a second marriage that has also dissolved (“Cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs” is her shorthand description of both breakups). Now, Payton, in addition to performing, directs the Archdiocese of Washington’s Mass Choir and runs the drama club at Elizabeth Seton High School. She makes the hours work with cooperation from Signature, with help from friends near the boy’s school and with the support of her mother, who still lives in the house in which Payton grew up.
It’s not clear what’s next. Payton is reluctant to hit the road again, but the Signature folks talk as though she won’t be sticking around.
“We are taking as much advantage of Nova Payton as we can while she’s still here,” Gardiner says. “Because she won’t be here for long, that’s for sure.”
“Nova is gifted,” Edelen says. “Gifted. She’s going to have to share that on a much bigger platform than just D.C.”
But can she get the roles she wants? Payton doesn’t accept that there can’t be black Elphabas in “Wicked” or Marias in “The Sound of Music.” She sees herself in shows as varied as “Annie” and next spring’s Broadway musical “Motown” (which she is keeping a keen eye on). Payton has a cabaret engagement slated for Signature in March, and its title seems appropriate: “Defying Gravity.”
“My grandmother would always say to not to let anything stop me,” says Payton, who lost her grandmother and her 103-year-old great-grandfather within the same week last month. “Just keep going, keep going. That’s just something that I have instilled in me.”
Book and lyrics by Tom Eyen, music by Henry Krieger. Directed by Matthew Gardiner. Signature Theatre through Jan. 6 at Signature Theatre, 4200 Campbell Ave., Arlington. Call 703-820-9771 or visit www.signature-theatre.org.