Editors' pick


Critic rating:
MPAA rating: R
Genre: Action/Adventure
This Dredd film stays true to the comic.
Starring: Lena Headey, Domhnall Gleeson, Karl Urban, Olivia Thirlby, Deobia Oparei, Langley Kirkwood, Jason Cope, Kevon Kane, Rakie Ayola, Joe Vaz
Director: Pete Travis
Running time: 1:36
Release: Opened Sep 21, 2012

Editorial Review

A thriller for fans to judge
By Sean O’Connell
Friday, September 21, 2012

Good news, Judge Dredd fans. Pete Travis’s savage interpretation of John Wagner’s futuristic law enforcer adheres to the character’s grim graphic-novel roots and proves far superior to the corny misfire attempted by Sylvester Stallone back in 1995.

This, finally, is the Dredd movie comic book readers have been anticipating.

Dreadful news, Dredd fans. If you also caught Gareth Evans’s like-minded Indonesian thriller “The Raid: Redemption” earlier this year, then “Dredd 3D” will strike you as derivative. Through no fault of Travis and his crew, the two movies follow near-identical blueprints (even though each filmed around the same time in separate locations). “The Raid” simply beat “Dredd” to theaters, stealing a bit of its thunder. They’re so similar, in fact, that Sony and Screen Gems could pull the plug on the American “Raid’ remake they currently have in the works, because it already exists and is opening under the name “Dredd 3D.”

Solemn Karl Urban (Bones in J.J. Abrams’s “Star Trek” reboot) dons the trademark helmet and motorcycle boots of Dredd, a ruthless judge presiding over the decaying, post-apocalyptic metropolis of Mega-City One. Two events complicate Dredd’s unremitting mission to clean up his streets. First, he’s saddled with a rookie partner (Olivia Thirlby) who’s bound to slow him down. Second, the duo is assigned to investigate an incident at Peach Trees, a towering apartment complex run by crazed drug dealer Ma-Ma (Lena Headey).

Ma-Ma manufactures and peddles SLO-MO, an illegal substance that does exactly what you’d imagine to an abuser’s brain. The drug’s chemical effect prompts Travis to employ slow-motion visual technology and exhilarating bullet-time effects in his multiple action sequences, which kick into graphic high gear once Dredd starts mowing down the opposition.

And here’s where the comparisons to “The Raid” become unavoidable. After Travis establishes Dredd as a take-no-prisoners law enforcer, the movie’s goal is to have our hero march from the ground floor of Peach Trees to Ma-Ma’s penthouse, eliminating waves of well-armed criminals in the process. Unlike “The Raid,” which dispensed of its antagonists through gracefully choreographed combat dances, “Dredd 3D” opts for satisfyingly bone-crunching brutality. Have you ever wondered what a bullet looks like as it travels through facial flesh? Because “Dredd” is going to show you.

There’s plenty for genre fans to appreciate in “Dredd.” It’s faithful to the British comic, which artist Carlos Ezquerra illustrated with an unnerving blend of grit, blood and sleaze. Headey is ridiculously good as the deranged Ma-Ma, playing the material so seriously that “Dredd” avoids the camp that swallowed Stallone’s take on the material. Thirlby’s a vast improvement over Rob Schneider from Stallone’s “Judge Dredd.” And Urban leaves Dredd’s mask on the entire time, which die-hard fans of the character will tell you is a must.

“Dredd 3D” is malicious, gory, masochistic and uncompromising. But it caters to its base like a presidential candidate on the campaign trail. Expect countless “Dredd” fans to vote at the box office with their ticket sales.

Contains strong bloody violence, drug use, lagnuage and some sexual content.