Editors' pick

Trummer's on Main

$$$$ ($25-$34)

Editorial Review

2013 Fall Dining Guide

2013 Fall Dining Guide
By Tom Sietsema
October 10, 2013

Austin Fausett came here in May from the venerated Inn at Little Washington, and the practice shows in much of the food he's serving in one of the region's best reasons to take a drive in the country. Picture scallop carpaccio, staged with kaffir lime froth and candied ginger in a pretty pink scallop shell. Imagine house-made pappardelle with soft folds of kale, a divine vegetarian dish sparked with big capers in a light tempura. Something as routine as a salad of beets and blue cheese seems new when it shows up as a parfait, and the chef does Low Country cooking proud with gremolata-topped osso buco ringed with creamed spinach, black-eyed peas and oven-dried tomatoes for tang. Fingers crossed, a vacherin will sweeten your visit, as it did mine this summer.

The ground floor is a convivial tavern that includes a private retreat that appears to have been airlifted from a castle; upstairs awaits a sweeping, butter-yellow "Winter Garden" with as many windows as Microsoft -- and inviting no matter the season.

Not every bite is wonderful; etoufee is timid, and doughnuts don't explain why the dessert's all the rage. Even so, Fausett, at 27, is a chef to watch.

2012 Spring Dining Guide

By Tom Sietsema
Sunday, May 20, 2012

Then: Brimming with surprises (2010)
Again: High-rise food on target

One of my favorite mom-and-pops in the area remains this three-story retreat in the charming hamlet of Clifton, where owners Stefan and Victoria Trummer continue to greet you as if you're good neighbors, and chef Clay Miller sends out food that makes the trip from anywhere worthwhile.

An elegant beaker of hot coconut milk thickened with pureed yucca is poured over a bowl of tender clams and diced pineapple, each spoonful electric with habanero. But Miller is just as content to display something wonderful he's found -- Alaskan snow crab one night -- without much more decoration than a backdrop of shaved ice and creamy yuzu mayonnaise for dipping.

The chef has a penchant for tall food these days. An already fat veal chop looks even bigger when it's served on a flat of creamed spinach sparked with cumin seeds. Chilean sea bass rises high with the help of oxtail ragout and crisp carrots at its base and a stack of tempura onion rings on its surface. The savories lean toward the rich: A tiny black pot of satiny mashed potatoes, served with that veal, tastes as much of butter as Yukon Golds.

Popcorn for dessert? Try it, you'll like it, especially as the snack is staged here, as velvety ice cream infused with the flavor of the movie snack. Garnishing the scoop is caramel popcorn, "steaming" with liquid nitrogen.

You will drink as swell as you sup, thanks to cocktails as tasty as any in the city and sommelier Tyler Packwood. His list encourages a diner to drink local with nearly 20 Virginia labels.

No matter the season, there's the sense of dining al fresco in the capacious Winter Garden, thanks to an endless ceiling, streams of light, grass displays on the table and a palette culled from nature.