Taylor: I thought she was very pretty. That was definitely the first thought that ran into my head. Definitely my type.
Katie: We shook hands. We started talking about things we’d done this weekend and started getting into what we do and what schools we went to.
Taylor: There was that first-date awkwardness that we definitely waded through — but it wasn’t uncomfortable. She’s an LSU fan, and I’m a big football fan, so that was a good common starting point.
Katie: I have a lot of nonprofit work that I’ve done before, and he works for a nonprofit, so that was similar. I feel like we did have a decent amount of things in common.
Taylor: She’s about a year or two older than me, but she graduated college probably three years ahead of me. So we’re just off by a little bit, nothing crazy but probably a half-step off in stages of life, I guess. She’s probably not the kind of person I’d pick out at a bar, but she was definitely cool, and I definitely warmed up to her as the evening went on.
He seemed more nervous than I. I don’t know if that’s his personality; maybe he’s a little more reserved or quiet. I’d say I had a little more command of the conversation.
Taylor: I’d say that’s a fair comment. It was probably a little first-date jitters and the whole experience of going into it not knowing what to expect.
It was friendly but nothing overly flirtatious. I usually like someone that’s a little more assertive and outgoing, but I did feel like we had a lot of things in common. I was probably cracking more jokes than he was, but I’d say we got along in that sense.
Taylor: I made her laugh a couple of times, so I think that was a good sign. We decided to nix the dessert, so we went to Buffalo Billiards to watch the end of the Capitals game. It was probably 9 or a little after. She [suggested] Buffalo Billiards. If she hadn’t said it, I would have.
Katie: We watched some of the end of the game, and we had a beer or two. Then we left there maybe at 10:15. We ended up hugging goodbye, and then he ended up asking for my number, which I was a little taken aback [by] — just with the assertive factor. That’s when he said he would be in touch with me. I think I would consider [going out again], but then again, I don’t know.
Taylor: I’ll probably give her a call sometime next week. It was a good time; she was cool.
RATE THE DATE
Katie: I’d [rate the date] a strong 3 [out of 5]. Overall I think it went well for what it was.
Taylor: Can I go with a 31
2? Definitely bordering on the romantically interested but still kind of unsure.