‘Primer’s’ Shane Carruth is in total control (once again) with ‘Upstream Color’
By Mark Olsen,
Nine years ago, Shane Carruth burst onto the independent film scene with “Primer,” a heady, complex sci-fi thriller that made time travel seem disturbingly plausible. Shot for only $7,000, the film took the Grand Jury Prize at the Sundance Film Festival, beating out more buzzworthy titles such as “Napoleon Dynamite” and “Garden State.” Carruth — a one-time software engineer — served as director, writer, producer, actor, cinematographer, editor, composer, casting director, production designer and sound designer.
So when Sundance programmers revealed their 2013 competition lineup, many of the film faithful immediately took notice that there among such high-profile names as Daniel Radcliffe and Rooney Mara was Carruth, back at last with a new film called “Upstream Color.” For a time, “Upstream Color” was trending higher on Twitter than “Sundance” itself.
Part of what made “Primer” so remarkable and Carruth such an intriguing figure was his apparent ability to do it all, a one-man-band approach to the more typically collaborative medium of feature filmmaking. It also made his subsequent silence of nearly a decade long seem that much louder.
With “Upstream Color,” Carruth is again director, writer, producer, cinematographer, composer, co-editor and actor. In the movie, a young woman (Amy Seimetz) is abducted and seemingly brainwashed via an organic material harvested from a specific flower. She later meets a man (Carruth), and after the two fall for each other, they come to realize that he may also have been subjected to the same process.
Now 40, Carruth still has a boyish handsomeness and quiet, intense charm about him, as well as a certain controlled asceticism — underscored when he ordered a salad with no dressing and a glass of water during a recent lunch. He is somewhat tight-lipped about what he was doing during his time away from the spotlight. He speaks of an ambitious sci-fi project called “A Topiary” as “the thing I basically wasted my whole life on.”
The frustration of that unrealized project seems to have spurred his autodidact polymath instinct to learn something new — how to market and release his own film — rather than depend on others to do things for him. So he’s adding distributor to his long list of jobs on “Upstream Color.”
With a pair of teaser clips already out online, a trailer will be released ahead of the film’s premiere Monday in Park City, Utah, with plans for a New York opening April 5. (A few select additional festival appearances and a handful of surprise pop-up screenings across the country will follow the film’s Sundance debut, and a Los Angeles opening is slated for mid-April.) The film will become available on digital and cable platforms soon after.
“The people that this is for, it will be for,” Carruth said of the audience he wants for “Upstream Color,” which he describes as “an earnest film,” explaining his desire to sell the film for what it is and not what a more conventional distributor might try to make it out to be. “Everything about the choice to do the distribution is about contextualizing” the movie, Carruth said during an interview in Los Angeles.
“I think he’s not interested in mediators. He’s not interested in having people speak for him or in speaking through others,” said Mark Urman, who was head of theatrical distribution at ThinkFilm when it released “Primer” after Sundance in 2004 and is now president and chief executive of the distribution company Paladin. “I think that’s his temperament. That’s his nature. I don’t think he wants to be dependent on apparatuses.”
Carruth was born in South Carolina but moved around the country as a child, his father being an Air Force sergeant. He attended high school outside Dallas before studying mathematics at Stephen F. Austin State University in Texas. After working as a software engineer for a short time, he dedicated himself to learning filmmaking and creating “Primer.”
“Upstream Color,” with its densely layered, thematically rich storytelling, is in part about the mutual psychosis that can be an essential part of romance, the agreement of a shared madness. It’s intense and hypnotically powerful, and it’s a more intimate and moving film than “Primer.” It’s somehow at once emotionally direct while narratively abstract.
In describing “Primer,” even the normally effusive festival notes called the film “intermittently incomprehensible.” This time around, Carruth seems eager to avoid such labels.
“What I don’t want is this whole concept of it being a puzzle movie, or ‘Primer’ being a puzzle movie,” Carruth said. “That’s not a fun little box to be in.”
Carruth hopes that by releasing the film himself, he can position it as he sees fit. “It’s not necessarily about revenue or that I don’t think it will sell. It’s that I get to frame this thing exactly the way I think it needs to be framed,” said Carruth, who recently moved from Dallas to New York.
“I get to continue narrating through marketing, releasing teasers and artwork that you could make the case aren’t the most commercial ways to sell this but they absolutely are in tune with the way I think of the film and what I want to communicate.”
Urman said that the only other filmmaker he had ever worked with who wanted to maintain as much overall control as Carruth was Vincent Gallo. He recalled teaming with Carruth on “Primer” as “a challenging experience. . . . I remember it vividly.”
“With a lot of independent filmmakers, they need a lot of information,” Urman said of walking a first-time filmmaker through marketing and distribution. “And with Shane, it was more of a tutorial. One definitely had the sense that as he was absorbing the information, he was already thinking of his own way to do it, and a better way to do it.”
Even with “Primer,” Carruth was forward-thinking in his dealmaking, taking less money upfront to hold on to the film’s rights and the possibility of making more in the long term.
“Primer” is now available for download via his own Web site and recently appeared on other digital outlets as he was planning how to release “Upstream Color.”
His mixture of curiosity and resolve has evolved into even rethinking the very purpose and value of a festival premiere.
“What most films would do if they’re going to be in the dramatic competition at Sundance is wait for a [sales] deal,” said Michael Tuckman of mTuckman Media, who is booking theaters for “Upstream Color.”
“I think that’s the real novel part of this: to be able to look in the mirror and say, are we going to wait for a seven-figure deal, or are we going to put our own plan in place and use Sundance not as an auction, but rather as part of a release plan?”
While Carruth acknowledges that he has taken out a loan for the distribution of “Upstream Color” and that he financed the film with his own money and contributions from friends — “it’s definitely money that comes from people that are not in film finance,” he said — he wants to keep many of the specifics of how “Upstream Color” came to be to himself.
“There are a few things I’m trying my best not to talk about,” said Carruth, “and that’s the tech specs on the camera and the workflow and the budget. Last time around, I was grateful to have some praise for ‘Primer,’ but they would say, ‘It’s a great movie for the budget.’ And I don’t ever want to hear that phrase again. It would be shocking, I think, if people knew, but I’m not going to tout it, and I hope it doesn’t ever get out.”
Perhaps just as Terrence Malick went from a period of artistic silence to his recent concentrated prolificness, Carruth now seems energized to enter a phase of new productivity. He plans to be shooting another film, currently titled “The Modern Ocean,” by this summer.
“I now know what I will be doing. I will be doing this,” Carruth said.
“I will be making films, and I’m going to keep working, no matter what I have to do. And I don’t plan to ever ask for permission from anybody.”
— Los Angeles Times