Analysis: How Tim Kaine won the Va. Senate race

Early in their race for U.S. Senate seat, George Allen’s campaign made a strategically important decision: to incessantly attack Timothy M. Kaine as a shill for President Obama and his liberal policies.

The move was either a savvy way for Allen to undermine the core message of Kaine’s candidacy, or a waste of money that fundamentally misread Virginia’s political direction.

A look at the Virginia Senate candidates’ records as governor

Laura Vozzella

The economy empowered Allen to enact an ambitious agenda, but forced Kaine to focus on recovery.

Allen’s record seen as mixed bag

Ben Pershing

The Va. candidate’s previous term in the Senate offers clues to how he would do if he wins a comeback bid.

Kaine makes ‘closing argument’ as campaigns debate momentum

Ben Pershing

The Democrat is up with two more ads in Virginia Senate race.

Warner makes radio ads for Tim Kaine

Laura Vozzella

Virginia’s most popular politician narrates a pair of new radio ads for Democrat Timothy M. Kaine.

Kaine keeps outraising Allen as outside spending tops $40 million

Ben Pershing

For the entire election cycle, Timothy Kaine has collected a total of $16.2 million while George Allen has raised $11.9 million.

George Allen makes direct appeal on defense cuts

Ben Pershing

Republican delivers message himself in latest ad.

More news about Va. politics

Va. GOP picks slate of staunch conservatives

Laura Vozzella

After election losses, state Republicans are largely resisting advice to move to the middle.

Cuccinelli formally nominated for Va. governor at convention

Errin Whack and Ben Pershing

Obenshain gets nod in attorney general’s race; lieutenant governor contest still undecided at convention.

Terry McAuliffe’s wife steps into campaign to defend him

Fredrick Kunkle

Dorothy McAuliffe says the Democratic candidate for Virginia governor respects women.

Read more

Repeatedly in their grueling 19-month contest, Allen (R) and Kaine (D) made starkly different calculations about the best way to win the seat of retiring Sen. James Webb (D), from money to message to the mood of the voters. Kaine’s team was proved right Tuesday night, as the Democrat claimed a narrow victory over his foe and Obama won the state, as well.

“We made a few assumptions early on,” Kaine adviser Mo Elleithee said election night. “We said a positive message might actually work. . . . The other side, very early in this campaign, made a strategic decision that they were going to be running against President Obama and trying to link Tim Kaine to the president. They lacked any forward-looking approach.”

Multiple advisers to the campaigns of the two former governors, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to talk frankly about internal deliberations, and outside experts agreed the contest was tight from beginning to end, underscoring the importance of every decision.

“These candidates were both pretty well known and well defined,” said Jennifer Duffy, a senior editor at the nonpartisan Cook Political Report. “There was not a lot of new information you were going to give voters about these guys.”

The Obama connection

Given that Kaine had just finished a stint as Obama’s choice for Democratic National Committee chairman, it was expected that his relationship with the president — and support for the administration’s health-care and stimulus legislation — would be an issue during the campaign.

But from the start Kaine refused to distance himself from Obama, instead agreeing with the president on most issues, even taking a speaking slot at the Democratic National Convention in Charlotte. Allen chose to make their ties a focus of his entire anti-Kaine message, warning the Democrat would be “Obama’s senator, not Virginia’s.”

Chris LaCivita, a GOP consultant who has worked for Allen, said tying Kaine to Obama was crucial because it dented Kaine’s preferred image as a moderate willing to work across the aisle.

The strategy, LaCivita said, “mitigated the ability for their side to say that Allen is nothing more than a partisan hack. Fighting that issue to a draw was a win for Allen.”

Rep. Gerald E. Connolly (D-Va.) disagreed.

“I think it actually backfired,” Connolly said. “This is not Wyoming. President Obama has maintained his popularity and standing in Virginia all along. He never collapsed in Virginia.”

Making up for ‘macaca’

If Kaine’s DNC service was a point of contention during the race, Allen had a much starker episode in his past to contend with — his “macaca” moment, when he used what many considered to be an ethnic slur against an Indian American Democratic campaign worker in his 2006 race against Webb. The incident sent his campaign off a cliff, ended talk of a 2008 presidential run and fed a narrative that Allen was ill-suited to the modern, diverse Virginia.