Macau's casinos rake in cash from Chinese who see gambling as an investment
By Andrew Higgins,
IN MACAU, CHINA At the end of a successful business trip to southern China, tire trader Yuan Shihao decided to make the most of his good fortune. Instead of catching a train home to Hunan province, he took a bus to Macau, a former Portuguese colony studded with casinos.
"I wanted to invest my earnings," Yuan explained. Only "fools," he said, put money in Chinese banks, which offer less interest than the rate of inflation.
The 30-year-old merchant spent the next 18 hours playing baccarat at the Golden Dragon Casino. Out of cash after a streak of bad luck, he took a break to pawn his watch and cellphone. Then he returned to the Golden Dragon and continued losing.
In all, Yuan blew nearly $15,000. He spent the night wandering Macau's neon-lighted streets, mocked by big signs offering Chinese New Year greetings: "Congratulations and Get Rich."
Thanks to Yuan and millions of other Chinese who flock here to the only patch of Chinese territory that allows casinos, Macau now rakes in more money from gambling than Las Vegas. On a recent weekend, nearly 170,000 mainland Chinese visited, crossing a border that separates this special administrative region from the rest of China.
When Beijing first took back Macau from Portugal in 1999, the ruling Communist Party's record of ferocious hostility to gambling suggested it might try to slow the roulette wheels. Instead, it approved a plan to open a gambling monopoly run by local tycoon Stanley Ho and let in big players from the United States and Australia. Since 2005, Macau's casino revenue has quadrupled. In the past year alone, it grew by nearly 60 percent to reach $23.5 billion.
"Nobody expected this kind of growth," said Manuel Joaquim das Neves, director of Macau's Gaming Inspection and Coordination Bureau. Neves, the son of a local woman and a Portuguese soldier, has a simple explanation: "It's the China effect."
Its general features are well known: blistering economic growth that last year pushed China ahead of Japan as the world's second-biggest economy, and a mountain of foreign currency that has made the country America's biggest foreign creditor.
The soaring fortunes of Macau's casinos, however, also hint at more volatile forces in China: a country awash with cash after a lending blowout by Chinese banks, a widening gulf between rich and poor, a frenzied pursuit of quick profit, and a financial system that penalizes ordinary savers and thus encourages risky speculation.
The gambling boom has also caused fallout in Macau: Casino magnate Ho, 89 and ailing, recently became embroiled in a raucous family feud over the division of his increasingly valuable assets among three wives and at least 16 children. "The problem with Stanley Ho is that he thought he is eternal. Nobody is eternal," said Neves, the gambling regulator, who has known the tycoon for years.
Some economists warn that the same fallacy afflicts thinking about China's sizzling economy, which has not only turbocharged Macau's casinos but also spurred feverish speculative investments, from real estate to bottles of Chateau Lafite Bordeaux. Sotheby's auction house last year increased wine sales in Hong Kong by 268 percent, to $52 million.
"I get asked about the 'bubble' word most days," said Robert Sleigh, head of wine for Sotheby's in Asia. "But you can't stop people from wanting something." Fine vintage wine, he said, is a "blue-chip investment."
An unusual feature of Chinese thinking on money, however, is that it often "mixes up investment and gambling," said Davis Ka-Chio Fong, director of the gaming studies center at the University of Macau. Fong, who co-wrote an academic paper on the phenomenon, said many mainland Chinese "see gambling as an investment and investment as a form of gambling."
His paper found, for example, that many in China view the stock market as being much the same as a casino - a potential source of "instant or quick rewards." Chinese banks, by contrast, are seen as a sure way to lose money: inflation far outpaces recently hiked but still-low interest rates on deposits.
Gamblers "are not rational, but they are not stupid: they know mathematics," Fong said. He noted that the vast bulk of Macau's casino revenue comes from a single game, baccarat, which offers slightly better odds than the alternatives.
Of Macau's total revenue from casinos last year, nearly three-quarters came from high rollers, mostly Chinese, playing baccarat. Unlike Yuan, the luckless tire trader, these gamblers place their bets in VIP rooms. Their travel, five-star hotel accommodations and even gambling money is arranged - often on credit - by a network of agents known as "junket collaborators." This system allows high-stakes Chinese gamblers to skirt restrictions that limit the total amount a person can take from the mainland each year to $50,000.
"Of course, this is illegal," Fong said. But it does mean that gamblers who lose on credit return to China safely: The agents who lend them money want to make sure they recover their cash.
The junket system highlights another problem at the core of the economic boom in Macau as well as China: rampant corruption.
A 2009 study based on reports in official Chinese media found that 57 percent of Chinese high-stakes gamblers in Macau are either government officials or senior managers in state-run companies, the main beneficiaries of easy credit from state-owned banks. On average, these officials and managers each lost $3.3 million - nearly all of it public money.
In one such case, for example, Li Weimin, the Communist Party chief in a town in southern China's Guangdong province, gambled away $11.5 million before his arrest in 2006. Though paid an official salary of only a few thousand dollars, Li lived in a 30-room house and owned other property worth millions. All the money he "invested" in gambling and real estate, according to police, was embezzled from government-owned businesses.
China has since imposed tighter restrictions on state employees traveling to Macau, limiting the number of trips they can make each year. Zeng Zhonglu of Macau Polytechnic Institute, a co-author of the 2009 study, believes this has had some effect and estimates that private businessmen have replaced officials and state-run enterprise managers as Macau's biggest source of revenue. But he also noted that since his study China has sharply curbed media reporting of officials who run amok in Macau.
The occasional account of a party official losing his shirt in Macau still trickles out. Shortly before the recent New Year holiday, a newspaper in the western Chinese city of Chongqing reported on a wayward local official dubbed the "gambling king," apparently as a warning to colleagues who might be planning a trip to Macau for the holiday. The official, Liu Xinyong, was said to have extorted $4 million in bribes and lost $250,000 of it during a two-day gambling spree in Macau.
"Liu Xinyong had two loves: His first love was power, his second gambling," reported the Chongqing Evening News. A court last year found Liu guilty of bribe-taking and consorting with criminal gangs. He is now on death row in Chongqing.
Neves, the director of the gaming bureau, thinks Macau's casinos have been given a bum rap. Chinese officials who get arrested for embezzling state money "use Macau as an excuse" to protect their stolen assets. "If they say they lost all their money in Macau, how can the government ever get it back?"