The Washington Post

Democrats are twice as likely to lose primaries as Republicans. So what’s Eric Cantor’s excuse?

Tuesday night's primary loss for House Majority Leader Eric Cantor came as a shock to some. Here are five other instances when the democratic process took the country by surprise. (Sarah Parnass/The Washington Post)

Eric Cantor's primary loss to David Brat last night was a surprise on a number of levels. For starters, it represents a prime example of the unintended consequences of redistricting gone awry. Moreover, no sitting majority leader has ever lost a primary since the office was created in 1899. And incumbents rarely lose primaries, period. Since 1968, only 130 representatives and 24 senators have lost primary contests, according to data compiled by Greg Giroux of Bloomberg news.


The data show that primary losses peak in the years following Congressional redistricting, when two incumbents can end up fighting for the same redrawn district. 1992 saw the greatest number of upsets, with 20 incumbents losing their seats to a primary challenger that year. 2012 was also a big year for primary turnover, with 7 Democrats and 7 Republicans losing their seats before the general election. So far this year only two incumbents have lost primaries - Eric Cantor, and Ralph Hall of Texas, both Republicans who were challenged from the right.


Historically, Democrats have been twice as likely to lose primaries as Republicans. They've tended to be the more fractious of the two parties, so this makes sense. In recent years, however, Democrats have been relatively unified while the GOP has dealt with internal divisions caused by the rise of the Tea Party. This has caused primary losses to even out between the parties. Since 2008, Democratic incumbents have lost 11 primary challenges, while Republicans have lost 16. All but two of those Republican losses were to Tea Party challenges from the right.


Similarly, Democrats have been twice as likely to lose primary fights due to redistricting. This has held true even in recent years. Since 2008, nearly half of Democratic primary losses (5 out of 11) have come from multiple incumbents fighting over the same redrawn district. But less than 20 percent of Republican primary losses (3 out of 16) have been due to redistricting.

This illustrates how successful Republicans have been at drawing Democratic seats out of existence. But Cantor's loss underscores the dangers of overenthusiastic gerrymandering. Virginia Republicans tweaked the boundaries of Cantor's district in 2010 to make it more conservative. This seemed like a great idea in 2012, when Cantor won his primary by a huge margin. But the unintended consequence was that the district became so conservative that it opened up Cantor to a challenge from the right, even though ideology-wise he's about as conservative as Michele Bachmann.

Christopher Ingraham writes about politics, drug policy and all things data. He previously worked at the Brookings Institution and the Pew Research Center.



Success! Check your inbox for details. You might also like:

Please enter a valid email address

See all newsletters

Show Comments
Most Read



Success! Check your inbox for details.

See all newsletters

Your Three. Videos curated for you.
Play Videos
Is fencing the answer to brain health?
Miss Manners: The technology's changed, but the rules are the same
Behind a famous and fast steam locomotive
Play Videos
This man's job is binge-watching for Netflix
How to survive a shark attack
What you need to know about trans fats
Play Videos
Michael Bolton's cinematic serenade to Detroit
How to avoid harmful chemicals in school supplies
Riding the X2 with D.C.'s most famous rapper
Play Videos
Full disclosure: 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, 1 ghoul
How to get organized for back to school
Pandas, from birth to milk to mom
Next Story
Dina ElBoghdady · June 11, 2014

To keep reading, please enter your email address.

You’ll also receive from The Washington Post:
  • A free 6-week digital subscription
  • Our daily newsletter in your inbox

Please enter a valid email address

I have read and agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Please indicate agreement.

Thank you.

Check your inbox. We’ve sent an email explaining how to set up an account and activate your free digital subscription.