Five Myths
Challenging everything you think you know

Correction:

An earlier version of this article incorrectly suggested that the Obama administration’s financial reforms included thousands of new rules. There have been hundreds of new rules. This version has been updated.

Five myths about Timothy Geithner

Noam Scheiber, a senior editor at the New Republic, is the author of “The Escape Artists: How Obama’s Team Fumbled the Recovery.”

Four years ago, it looked like Timothy Geithner might not survive his confirmation hearings, much less complete a term as Treasury secretary. A background check revealed that he hadn’t paid payroll taxes for more than two years while working at the International Monetary Fund. Meanwhile, his chief qualification for the Treasury job was his tour as president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, where he executed President George W. Bush’s bank bailout. Today, Geithner leaves office as one of the most important Treasury secretaries in history, having helped rescue the economy from collapse. Clearly there were a few things we misunderstood about him. Here are five of the biggest.

1. He is a creature of Wall Street.

When even the wife of Rahm Emanuel believes you’re a Goldman Sachs alumnus, it’s going to be tough to convince the country otherwise. But the truth is that before taking over as Treasury secretary in 2009, Geithner spent 20 years in public service, save for a few months at the Council on Foreign Relations.

Five Myths

A feature from The Post’s Outlook section that dismantles myths, clarifies common misconceptions and makes you think again about what you thought you already knew.

Archive

More from Outlook

How Obama undermines the press

How Obama undermines the press

Leonard Downie on the war on leaks.

Five myths about tornadoes

Five myths about tornadoes

Why earlier warnings aren’t always better.

The case for female military leaders

The case for female military leaders

How to change the military’s culture.

He worked at Treasury for more than a decade, including a tour as an attache in Tokyo, before joining the IMF and the New York Fed — but he’s never worked on Wall Street. His only private-sector experience came at Henry Kissinger’s consulting firm right out of grad school.

Not surprisingly, Geithner has been defensive about his apocryphal investment-banking past. Appearing at a House Democratic retreat not long after his Senate confirmation in 2009, he blurted out: “I never worked for Goldman. I never worked on Wall Street. I don’t come from money.”

If there was a problem with Geithner’s relationship to the financial sector, it wasn’t corruption but intellectual capture. Geithner spent his two decades as a bureaucrat adopting many of the views of the financial-sector elite. When he was New York Fed president, several titans of finance sat on his board of directors. So it came as no surprise when he told me in 2011 that preserving Wall Street’s outsize role in the economy was one of the keys to America’s strength. “I don’t have any enthusiasm for . . . trying to shrink the relative importance of the financial system in our economy,” he said.

2. Geithner is mild-mannered and understated.

For years, Geithner’s slight frame and boyish looks have inspired doubts about his toughness. Pete Peterson, a financier who once chaired the New York Fed’s board of directors, told me that, before he hired Geithner as the bank’s president, he “wanted to be sure the soft-spokenness, the diffidence, didn’t translate into a lack of courage.” He need not have worried. As Geithner’s mentor Larry Summers reassured Peterson, Geithner was “the only person who ever worked with me who’d walk into my office and say to me, ‘Larry, on this one, you’re full of ­­
s---’. ”

This bluntness was a hallmark of Geithner’s tenure at Treasury, at least behind closed doors. When he decided that infighting among regulators could derail Wall Street reform in 2009, he told the heads of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) that their behavior was “[expletive]” ridiculous, advising them to speak with one voice rather than look out for their own turf. In spring 2011, after Standard & Poor’s said it planned to downgrade its outlook on the U.S. credit rating, Geithner summoned the company’s top officials to Treasury and told them they knew little about how deficit reduction worked in Washington. It’s not your “comparative advantage,” he told them, according to one participant.

3. He had a relatively free hand in setting economic policy.

Even though Geithner ranks as one of the most influential Treasury secretaries in history, he often didn’t get his way on key policy decisions. He was an early opponent of the “Volcker Rule,” a proposal from former Fed chairman Paul Volcker to forbid government-backed banks from gambling like hedge funds. But Geithner did an about-face once it became clear that the president was enthusiastic about the idea.

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges