Outlook’s 4th Annual Spring Cleaning

Throw out the president’s Cabinet

Our lives are cluttered with unnecessary traditions, ideas and institutions. Warm weather came early this year, but there's still time for a good spring cleaning. After purging old receipts, broken appliances and unloved outfits, what else should we toss? Outlook asked 10 writers what they thought we'd be better off without. From the Cabinet to premium gas to chick flicks, here are their picks.

Quick: Who’s the secretary of commerce? How about the head of the Small Business Administration?

The correct answer to both of those questions should be:

Cast Your Vote

What did we miss?

What did we miss?

Add your ideas in comments, on Facebook, on Twitter (#springclean) or e-mail us.

More on this Story

View all Items in this Story

A) I don’t know

B) I don’t care

C) Both A and B

The president’s Cabinet is an anachronism in today’s Washington, where important decisions are made almost entirely by White House officials. Worse, the Cabinet has become a symbol of the federal government’s excess and bureaucracy.

Rick Perry famously proposed eliminating four — oops! — three Cabinet agencies. A better idea is not to eliminate the government functions but to get rid of the figureheads whose power doesn’t come close to their ceremonial status, including places in the presidential line of succession and prime seats at the State of the Union address.

Of the 22 Cabinet-level positions, only four are necessary — the same four George Washington had in his Cabinet: secretary of state, secretary of defense (or war, in Washington’s case), secretary of the Treasury and attorney general.

The Cabinet meeting, once a crucial forum for creating and debating national policy, is now a mere photo-op. The Cabinet meetings that President Obama has every couple of months exist almost entirely to make it look as if actual work is occurring. New York Magazine last year quoted a Democratic source asserting that half a dozen Cabinet members hadn’t had a single phone conversation with Obama in their first two years on the job.

Cabinet officers have become figureheads by design. Because they are appointed with Senate confirmation, they can be hauled before Congress to answer questions. The president, therefore, has a powerful incentive to keep them out of the loop. White House advisers, by contrast, are often protected by executive privilege. These officials, many of them young and unknown, are the ones who hold the real power over the Cabinet members, who exist largely as defenders of budgetary turf.

Let’s clear ’em out. Then you will never again feel a sense of panic when somebody asks: Who’s the secretary of housing and urban development? For the record, it’s Shaun Donovan. But really, you shouldn’t care.


Dana Milbank is a Washington Post op-ed columnist.

Read more from Outlook, including our 2011 spring cleaning.

Friend us on Facebook, and follow us on Twitter.

Read what others are saying