Prince George’s police get away with a beating

ON THE EVENING of March 3, 2010, two Prince George’s County police officers, clad in riot gear and wielding nightsticks, beat an unarmed and unthreatening University of Maryland student named John J. McKenna during rowdy street celebrations in College Park following the university’s men’s basketball victory over Duke. The beating was swift, savage and unprovoked; Mr. McKenna had simply been skipping down the street when he encountered the police who slammed him to the ground and pummeled him. Eight metal staples were needed to close a wound to his scalp.

Afterward the police lied about the incident until a video surfaced that exposed their fabrications; even then, they covered up the officers’ identities for months. At trial, a judge with a possible conflict of interest, which she failed to disclose until questioned about it, showed glaring bias in favor of the officers. In the end, one of the officers got off scot-free; the other was given a slap on the wrist; and no higher-ups in the police department were called to account.

Washington Post Editorials

Editorials represent the views of The Washington Post as an institution, as determined through debate among members of the editorial board. News reporters and editors never contribute to editorial board discussions, and editorial board members don’t have any role in news coverage.

Read more

Latest Editorials

Apple shifts its tax burden

Editorial Board

But it’s the tax code, not Apple, that’s rotten to the core.

Stop micromanaging D.C. schools

Editorial Board

City council should rebuff education committees recommendations.

In Burma, a glimmer of hope

Editorial Board

But progress has to be made before the U.S. rewards it.

This is a travesty of justice. Let’s take a look at who is responsible.

Start with the Prince George’s police department, which engaged in a conspiracy of silence and coverup. Initially, the police accused Mr. McKenna in court documents of attacking and injuring a mounted police officer; they said his injuries resulted from being kicked by a horse. This was an invention, as the video showed. If Mr. McKenna was guilty of anything, it was of being oblivious.

Yet no one in the police department came forward with the truth or even, for several months, the identity of the officers who beat Mr. McKenna, even though plenty of them saw what happened. (The police, who wore helmets with visors during the beating, were identified to prosecutors only when a new chief, Mark A. Magaw, took office and cracked the whip.)

Even after the video surfaced, and even after the county paid Mr. McKenna $2 million in damages after he filed a civil suit, the officers who beat him continued receiving their pay for more than two years while on administrative leave. The officer convicted of the beating, James Harrison Jr., was allowed to retire last month — with his pension. Under state rules, he will not be allowed to work again as a police officer in Maryland.

Then there was the unprofessional conduct of the Prince George’s County Circuit Court judge, Beverly J. Woodard, who presided at the officers’ trial. Ms. Woodard was previously married to a Prince George’s police officer who himself was convicted in 1988 for repeatedly shooting an unarmed suspect in the back, as he lay on the ground, with a confiscated BB gun. When she was assigned to handle a trial involving a similar case of alleged police misconduct and assault, she should have at least disclosed that fact, if not recused herself. She did neither.

She withheld the information until asked about it during the trial by a journalist, Brad Bell of WJLA-TV. At that point she summoned counsel for both sides into her chambers and, in an emotional meeting, refused to declare a mistrial, insisting that she could be fair. Her reasoning remains unknown because she did not allow a court reporter into the meeting.