RIO DE JANEIRO — Rio de Janeiro’s Olympic golf course faces an uncertain future after a court proposed Wednesday that the under-construction layout should be modified to meet environmental concerns.
Judge Eduardo Klausner, hearing a lawsuit brought against the city of Rio de Janeiro and the course developer, said the defendants had to return on Sept. 17 to say if they could accept the proposal. Klausner said work on the course could continue, but no new areas of vegetation could be plowed under.
In recent months, golf architects have been putting down grass on the course, hoping to finish by the end of the year and avoid delays. That would give the grass two growing seasons to mature — a minimum for a top course.
Golf’s return to the 2016 Olympics for the first time in 112 years was to be a centerpiece of the Rio de Janeiro Games. But the course has been plagued by legal challenges over land ownership, questions about its location in a nature reserve, and other delays that date back almost five years.
Mario Andrada, a spokesman for the local Olympic organizing committee, tried to find an upside.
“We are happy the construction on the course has not been stopped,” he told The Associated Press. He declined further comment.
In a raucous, at times chaotic two-hour-long hearing, Klausner heard the concerns of environmentalists, biologists and Rio city hall’s top environmental official, as well as attorneys from both sides.
Klausner played the role of mediator, nudging the public prosecutors, who brought the suit, to offer a proposal that would preserve as much of the Atlantic rainforest area as possible while allowing the golf course to continue.
“It is in society’s interests that the Olympics take place and it’s also in society’s interests that the environment be preserved,” he said. “What has to be observed is legality, and within legality is respect for the environment.”
A forest engineer with the state environment secretariat, Isabela Lobato da Silva, who visited the forested area before construction on the golf course began, said that while some forested areas have already been destroyed, the damage was not irreversible. She proposed the creation of a 400 meter-(yard-) wide corridor to allow for the circulation of animals between the wooded areas on either side of the golf course.
Lawyers for the defendants repeatedly stated that because land was broken on the golf course about a year and a half ago, any changes at could prove catastrophic.
A biologist hired by the developer said that since the course layout has been set, it would prove difficult for it to be modified. The city’s Environment Secretary, Carlos Alberto Muniz, said that 10 days was too short to get approval from all parties including the local organizing committee.
A spokesman for the Switzerland-based International Golf Federation was not immediately available for comment.
However, in a recent interview Ty Votaw, vice president of the IGF, said there were alternative plans if changes demanded them.
“There are contingency plans,” Votaw said, speaking at the British Open. “What they are is not something we’re going to share right now, but there are contingency plans.”
In a separate interview at the British Open, Votaw hinted the course was not going be as good as it could be.
“It’s probably not going to be as perfect as our ideal situation would be,” he said.
Golf course architect Gil Hanse has been encouraged in recent months as grass has been sewn. Organizers hope for a test event late in 2015 or early in 2016.
Activists suggested that financial and real estate interests, and not any real need for a new course, were the behind the push to build the Olympic course. Klausner stated it was not for him to judge the merits of another golf course specifically for the Olympics — Rio already has two.
The developer of the course project is Italy-born Pasquale Mauro, one of the largest landowners in the Barra da Tijuca area.
Plans call for the course, being built in suburban Rio near the heart of most games’ venues, to be public after the Olympics. However, this egalitarian ambition seems at odds with what’s to be built alongside the course on some of the area’s last undeveloped real estate.
A complex of 160 luxury apartments in four 20-story towers are to go up overlooking the course. Prices ranges from about $2.5 million to $7 million with completion set for a year after the Olympics end.
Environmental activist Marcello Mello, who has been campaigning against the golf course, hailed the proposal as a victory, though he added “we wanted to see the entire course moved.”
Jenny Barchfield on Twitter: http://twitter.com/JennyBarchfield
Stephen Wade on Twitter: http://twitter.com/StephenWadeAP
Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.