A couple of years ago I asked Jimmy Johnson what he saw as the biggest problem holding the Redskins back. Why, I asked, were they locked in such a decade-long stasis, why was it that no matter how many coaching changes, and no matter how many times they remade the roster, they still fought to be an 8-8 team. He answered without hesitation, “Quarterback play.”
I’ve heard all the arguments against making Manning a Redskin — they can’t protect him, they don’t have enough big targets for him — and they are nonsense. Manning’s line was plenty iffy in Indianapolis the last couple of years, and just look what he did behind it. It’s amazing how brilliant quarterbacking, the ability to scan, adjust the play at the line of scrimmage and get rid of the ball quickly and to the right place, solves apparently pressing roster issues.
In the wake of the Giants' 21-17 upset victory over the Patriots in Super Bowl XLVI, the Post Sports Live crew debates whether Tom Brady or Eli Manning is more likely to win another Super Bowl.
Always outside the fray, Kirk Cousins is gettting the shot he deserves, albeit in most dysfunctional way possible.
Robert Griffin III gave his most encouraging performance of the season after being told to sit down.
Robert Griffin III should be grateful for being spared the final three games of this disaster of a season.
Decision to bench starter escalates showdown between Coach Mike Shanahan and owner Dan Snyder..
Redskins players and coaches are being undermined by owner Dan Snyder’s corrosive star culture.
Whether the Redskins should try to get Manning, and whether they can are two different questions, of course. But the suspicion here is the Redskins have a decent chance. It’s said that Miami will be the favorite because it has more talent, and Manning owns a home there. But the Dolphins also have an unproven factor in Joe Philbin, who though a superb offensive coordinator for the Packers, is a rookie head coach at the age of 50. How many times have we seen hot coordinators win head coaching jobs only to flame out?
Shanahan is the only head coach in the market for Manning’s services who can say he’s won two Super Bowls, and knows how to work with a fully formed Hall of Famer. He can also say he has made real strides in rebuilding, despite the Redskins’ record. Their defense has shown vast improvement, a young roster exhibits real promise in some areas, they’ve made good additions on the offensive line with more on the way, have a record of smart drafts the last couple of years, and made some solid discoveries among undrafted free agents. Their only real personnel failure has been in finding a quarterback.
It’s likely that to get Manning they may have to promise to bring in some players to accompany him, chiefly another pass-catcher and some offensive linemen. But they were going to do that anyway. As it happens there are some intriguing players who could be available through free agency, from DeSean Jackson to Reggie Wayne.
The pitch to Manning should be: come lay down a cornerstone and be part of returning the Redskins to greatness. There is no better or more appreciative city in which to be champion, none. There’s one more thing the Redskins can offer. They have an owner who has shown a willingness to open his wallet when needed, who is not afraid of spending money to buy excitement. It’s finally time to use that to their advantage.
For Sally Jenkins’s previous columns, go to washingtonpost.com/jenkins.