Canada’s guest worker program could become model for U.S. immigration changes

Then there are the other elements of the Canadian system that U.S. labor unions and farm worker advocates say they would not want to see copied.

Once in Canada, the workers live like monks, sleeping in trailers or barracks, under contractual agreements that forbid them from drinking alcohol and having female visitors, or even socializing with other Mexican workers from different farms.

Gallery

Latest stories from Foreign

North Korea sends signals it may be willing to rejoin disarmament talks

North Korea sends signals it may be willing to rejoin disarmament talks

Chinese media report that a special envoy relayed the North’s willingness to resume negotiations.

Kerry, in Africa, keeps focus on Middle East

Kerry, in Africa, keeps focus on Middle East

Secretary of state discusses Mideast peace efforts with Egypt’s Morsi during the African Union summit.

Turkish trade undeterred by detours

Turkish trade undeterred by detours

Instead of crossing Syria, Turkey’s truckers now sail around it, driving home an age-old truth: In war, commerce improvises.

12 killed in blast at Afghan mosque

12 killed in blast at Afghan mosque

Officials say Taliban insurgents placed explosives in a corner of the mosque before joining worshipers.

Over protests, Israel plans to double prayer space at Western Wall

Over protests, Israel plans to double prayer space at Western Wall

The plan is aimed at appeasing American Jews and accommodating liberal Judaism at the Old City wall.

Most of their time in Canada is limited to sleeping, eating and working long days that can stretch to 15 hours, without overtime pay.

“People look to Canada as a model for their success at making temporary workers truly temporary,” said David FitzGerald, an immigration expert at the University of California at San Diego. “But the way they are prevented from staying is by socially isolating them to an extreme degree, controlling their movements and systematically preventing them from interacting with Canadian society,” he said.

“From a labor rights perspective, it’s troubling, but it’s appealing to policymakers because it keeps the workers temporary,” FitzGerald said.

‘Everything is nice there’

Still, migrants interviewed here in the high desert towns of rural Zacatecas said work in Canada is hard but fair and well-paid. Their employers treated them well, they said, and when they didn’t, the local Mexican consulate intervened.

“The consulate threatens to take away their Mexicans, and usually that’s enough,” said Armando Tenorio, who first worked in Quebec tending flowers and herbs inside a massive greenhouse.

Now Tenorio spends eight months on a berry farm outside Vancouver and comes home every winter with thousands in savings and duffel bags stuffed with chocolate-covered blueberries.

“Everything is nice there. It’s not all disorganized like this,” he said, back in his home town of Troncoso, where armed men park their pickups on the hill near his house at night, watching the highway below as lookouts for drug traffickers.

Like many workers here, he said he’s torn between the need to earn money and the long separations from his wife and daughter.

“Honestly, I’d rather be able to do work in the United States and bring my family with me,” he said. “But only with a visa.”

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges

    Blast kills 12 at Afghan mosque