Horsemeat scandal dents Europe’s culinary self-image

STEPHAN JANSEN/EPA - A horse butchery is pictured in Munich, Germany. The horsemeat scandal spreads across Europe after horse meat falsely labeled as beef was discovered in lasagnas and burgers in Britain, Ireland, Sweden and France.

PARIS — According to folklore, Europeans have always treated their food with reverence, eating Grandma’s slow-cooked stews concocted with farm-fresh ingredients while Americans wolfed down the genetically modified, chemically preserved junk that is symbolized by burgers and fries.

Over the past two weeks, however, Europeans have watched an unfolding meat-fraud scandal expose a multinational network of traders, factory owners and marketers for whom food is a stateless commodity that can be hashed up, frozen and shipped around the continent to be profitably passed off as genuine cuisine to Swedes, Italians, Czechs or French alike.

epa03714567 A Thai Buddhist family take an offering of lotus flowers to pay respects to a giant Buddha surrounded by more than 1,000 smaller Buddha statues at a Buddhism Park, on Vesak or Visakha Bucha day, in Nakhon Nayok, north of Bangkok, Thailand, 24 May 2013. Buddhist devotees throughout the world offer blessings at temples to mark one of the holiest days in Buddhism, commemorating the birth, enlightenment and the death of Buddha. EPA/BARBARA WALTON

Photos of the day

Buddhist Wesak festival, POW reunion, bridge collapse, world’s largest Lego model and more.

Latest stories from Foreign

12 killed in blast at Afghan mosque

12 killed in blast at Afghan mosque

Officials say Taliban insurgents placed explosives in a corner of the mosque before joining worshipers.

North Korea sends signals it may be willing to rejoin disarmament talks

North Korea sends signals it may be willing to rejoin disarmament talks

Chinese media report that a special envoy relayed the North’s willingness to resume negotiations.

Kerry, in Africa, keeps focus on Middle East

Kerry, in Africa, keeps focus on Middle East

Secretary of state discusses Mideast peace efforts with Egypt’s Morsi during the African Union summit.

Turkish trade undeterred by detours

Turkish trade undeterred by detours

Instead of crossing Syria, Turkey’s truckers now sail around it, driving home an age-old truth: In war, commerce improvises.

Over protests, Israel plans to double prayer space at Western Wall

Over protests, Israel plans to double prayer space at Western Wall

The plan is aimed at appeasing American Jews and accommodating liberal Judaism at the Old City wall.

So much for Grandma.

The scandal erupted Feb. 7 when Britain’s Food Standards Agency discovered horsemeat mixed into frozen lasagna labeled as 100 percent beef. Horse-loving Britons, who would never think of eating Black Beauty, were shocked, all the more so in that the lasagna came from across the English Channel.

“It’s a straight fraud,” said Britain’s environment minister, Owen Paterson, giving voice to the outrage of English consumers. “If a product says it’s beef and you’re actually buying horse, that is a fraud.”

But that was just the beginning. By Tuesday, the shock had spread across Europe, even to countries such as France, where people routinely eat horsemeat. Prepared dishes labeled as beef, it turned out, have been commonly laced with cheaper horsemeat and sold at frozen-food counters across the continent. There is no telling how long the cheating has been going on or how much is undiscovered.

In reaction, frozen dishes such as shepherd’s pie, pizza and meatballs have been withdrawn from hundreds of multinational-chain supermarkets in at least 16 countries. A dozen national investigations have been launched. The European Union has vowed to require meat merchants to conduct costly DNA testing. French President Francois Hollande said that all meat products sold in France must bear a label of origin, just like wine.

“The entire sector has fallen victim to a fraud without precedent,” said Jean-Rene Buisson, president of the French National Association of Food Industries.

For many Europeans, the issue was less disgust at eating horsemeat than the dishonesty involved in false labeling. But Fabrice Nicolino, a journalist who writes about the food industry and the environment, warned that testing could well turn up unhealthy residue from anti-inflammatory drugs that are often administered to horses.

“Nobody really knows what industrial meat contains,” he wrote Monday in Le Monde.

Perhaps even more unsettling was the spotlight suddenly directed at a modern agro-industry that, with few people noticing, has left picturesque farmers’ markets far behind and, instead, trades in bulk food across borders much as other industries trade in diamonds or oil.

Giving the lie to images of rosy-cheeked peasants and busy family kitchens, more than 90 percent of European households at least occasionally buy ready-made frozen dishes, according to industry research. Britain and Germany lead European consumption of such dishes, but France is not far behind in third place.

More food content

Show Me:
Show more

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges

    Blast kills 12 at Afghan mosque