Despite unprecedented criticism, Egyptian military still a revered institution

CAIRO — When Egyptian protesters overthrew Hosni Mubarak’s 30-year autocracy last year, they initially embraced the long-hallowed armed forces as revolutionary guardians. But that amity quickly decayed amid reports of troops firing on demonstrators and abusing women, and suffered further when an interim junta delayed the democratic transition and stripped powers from the president.

Yet despite the unprecedented ire centered on military chiefs who had never faced public scrutiny, there are very few signs of a dent in the vaunted reputation of the Egyptian armed forces at large.

Latest stories from Foreign

Obama and Putin fail to resolve differences over Syria

Scott Wilson

President’s three-day European visit begins with an ad dress to students and the launch of a G-8 summit.

Chinese activist Chen says Beijing pressuring him out of NYU

Gillian Wong

New York University officials puzzled by allegations, say Chen’s fellowship ending on schedule

Syrians fleeing war find more misery in Greece

Michael Birnbaum

Economic meltdown leaves little help for thousands of desperate refugees.

World Digest: June 17, 2013

Southern Egyptians angered by Islamist appointment; Bulgarian premier calls security pick a mistake.

Impasse in Assange saga continues

Karla Adam

No diplomatic breakthrough comes in the standoff between Britain and Ecuador over the WikiLeaks founder.

Even among demonstrators chanting strident, once-unthinkable slogans in Tahrir Square last week — “Down with military rule!” — it was not difficult to find people such as Tarek Abo Elnaga, 16, who said he dreams of becoming an officer, or Medhat Mohamed, who said he would enlist in a heartbeat, even at age 45, “for my nation.”

The public admiration could bode well for stability. But as the generals fade from the spotlight, analysts say it could also hinder civilian efforts to wrest real control of parliament and military matters — something likely to require backing from a population that is tired of protest and looking for leadership from President Mohamed Morsi, who was sworn in last week.

“It’s definitely going to make the president’s — or whatever civilian institution’s — task all that much more difficult,” said Yasser el-Shimy, an Egypt-based analyst with the International Crisis Group. “It’s one thing to revolt against Mubarak. It’s completely another to revolt against the military.”

Since the revolution, there have been few reports of unrest within the Arab world’s largest military, which receives about $1.3 billion in U.S. funding annually. A blogger who cast himself as Egypt’s first conscientious objector was arrested and now lives in Germany, and his anti-conscription movement has only about a dozen members.

In an inauguration speech last Sunday, Morsi said the armed forces would “go back to the barracks.” But even before he spoke, the audience of dignitaries and former parliamentarians chanted that Egyptians and the army are one.

“The majority of Egyptians are very much pro-SCAF and pro-military,” said Sameh Saif el-Yazl, a retired army general and security analyst who is viewed as close to the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces. “People look to the army as the final salvation.”

Polls taken before the elections support his claim. A Gallup survey conducted in April found that Egyptians’ confidence in the military had dropped little since June 2011, from 95 to 89 percent. A Pew Research Center survey this spring indicated that three-quarters of Egyptians believe the military has a good influence. Both surveys found that majorities viewed the council of generals positively.

The military’s standing was built over decades of dictatorial rule by presidents who hailed from the armed forces and was aided by censorship laws that prohibit reporting on the military, shielding it from examination.