U.S. lawmakers question military aid to Egypt, citing concerns about Israel

(Brendan Smialowski/ AFP/Getty Images ) - In the Senate, Oklahoma Republican James M. Inhofe, right, the new ranking member of the Armed Services Committee, called on Jan. 31 for a temporary halt of military aid to Egypt, including a fleet of 20 F-16 planes being shipped this year.

(Brendan Smialowski/ AFP/Getty Images ) - In the Senate, Oklahoma Republican James M. Inhofe, right, the new ranking member of the Armed Services Committee, called on Jan. 31 for a temporary halt of military aid to Egypt, including a fleet of 20 F-16 planes being shipped this year.

Concerned about Egypt’s political instability and the U.S. budget crunch, a growing number of American lawmakers are challenging the wisdom of providing $1.3 billion a year in military aid to Cairo, arguing that the policy is overdue for a wholesale review.

Lawmakers say that Washington’s largess, which includes large fleets of M1A1 tanks and F-16 fighter jets, could backfire, given the unpredictability of Egypt’s Islamist-led government and its fraught relationship with Israel.

Gallery

Latest from National Security

U.S. acknowledges four Americans killed in counterterrorism missions

U.S. acknowledges four Americans killed in counterterrorism missions

Attorney General Eric Holder informs Congress of deaths one day before major speech by President Obama.

Man tied to Boston bombing suspect killed in encounter with FBI, others

Man tied to Boston bombing suspect killed in encounter with FBI, others

Ibragim Todashev implicated himself and Tamerlan Tsarnaev in a triple homicide two years ago, officials say.

Fine Print: For Senate panel, there’s power and limitations on Syria

Fine Print: For Senate panel, there’s power and limitations on Syria

Despite passage of bill calling for aid, Foreign Relations Committee should watch its step on pushing Obama.

Iran paving over suspected nuclear-related testing site, U.N. agency says

Iran paving over suspected nuclear-related testing site, U.N. agency says

Officials believe the facility may have been used to test a special kind of detonator used in atomic weapons.

Judge apologizes for lack of transparency in leak probe

Judge apologizes for lack of transparency in leak probe

Leak-investigation documents related to Fox reporter James Rosen were erroneously kept under seal.

Washington’s increasingly controversial aid package to Egypt, a titan in the Middle East, is on the agenda this weekend when Secretary of State John F. Kerry meets with Egyptian leaders in Cairo. Kerry has argued that disengaging from Egypt would be a mistake, but he will have to contend with louder calls for a review of a policy established decades ago, in a vastly different political context.

Critics of Egypt in the House and Senate have introduced bills this year seeking a temporary halt or outright end to shipments of military supplies to Egypt. While the bills have not drawn widespread support, the arguments that underpin them have gotten significant traction, members of Congress said in interviews.

“Why are we giving billions to Egypt, when in my mind it is not a friend of America?” said Rep. Vern Buchanan (R-Fla.), who recently introduced a bill calling for a suspension of military and civilian assistance to Egypt. “We’re drowning in a sea of debt. Why are we spending so much money in a part of the world that doesn’t like us?”

In the Senate, James M. Inhofe (R-Okla.), the new ranking member of the Armed Services Committee, called on Jan. 31 for a temporary halt of military aid to Egypt, including a fleet of 20 F-16 planes being shipped this year. Inhofe said the suspension would send a strong message to Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi, a member of the Muslim Brotherhood, a conservative Islamist group. Morsi has sought to curb the authority of the country’s vaunted military, a historically secular institution that has maintained a discreet working relationship with Israel.

“Egypt’s military is our friend,” Inhofe said in a statement explaining his bill. “Morsi is our enemy.”

A few Democrats, including Rep. Juan Vargas (D-Calif.), who sits on the Foreign Affairs Committee, have joined the
Republican-led efforts.

“I would hate to see American weapons, sophisticated F-16s, being used against Israel,” Vargas said in an interview. “We’ve seen historically, it could happen again, especially with the radicalization of Egypt.”

Egypt and Israel have been the top recipients of U.S. foreign aid since 1979, when Washington brokered a landmark peace deal between the dueling nations. The Camp David Accords remain the main pillar of U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East.

Ensuring that Cairo continues to adhere to the terms of the deal, which is explosively unpopular on the Egyptian street, is the Obama administration’s leading incentive to continue the aid. But the United States has other interests, including continued naval access to the Suez Canal, which connects the Indian Ocean and the Mediterranean. It also wants to help Egypt restore order in the Sinai Peninsula, a large desert stretch bordering Israel that has become a breeding ground for Islamist militants.

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges