|
At a time when tax relief is routinely available to
help parents with the costs of child care and
college, Congress finally seems poised to pass
some measure of tax relief to help parents with the
costs of elementary and secondary education.
Bipartisan legislation has been introduced in the
Senate and the House to expand existing college education
savings accounts (ESAs) by increasing the maximum
allowable annual contribution from $500 to
$2,000, and by allowing the accounts to be used not
only for college costs, but also for expenses associated
with K-12 education.
Education savings accounts are designed to benefit
all children, whether they attend public, private,
religious, or home schools. For a child attending any
school, this money could be used for fees, books/supplies,
a home computer, transportation costs, special
diagnostic/remedial services, after-school programs,
or a tutor. For private and religious school children,
the accounts could also be used to cover tuition.
Education savings accounts would empower parents
to deal with the specific needs of their own children.
For example, if a child has a special learning disability,
such as dyslexia, which requires special attention,
dollars could be applied directly on that problem.
Or perhaps the child has a math deficiency and
needs a tutor, or there is a need for transportation to
an after-school program.All these specific needs cannot
necessarily be addressed by general education
funds, but could be addressed by education savings
accounts. Parent-directed dollars would get right to
the heart of the problem.
Who Could Establish an Education Savings Account?
Almost any individual or corporation could establish
an education savings account for a child, though
each child could have only one account established in
his/her name with a total maximum annual contribution
of $2,000. Thus, grandparents, relatives, and
friends could set up an education savings account, and
corporations could use them as a way to assist with
the education of low-income children. As is the case
with existing college education accounts, certain high-income
taxpayers would be disqualified from contributing
to the accounts. Although contributions to
an ESA would not be tax deductible, the interest that
would accumulate would be tax free, and withdrawals
would not be subject to taxation if used for qualified
expenses.
Who Would Benefit from Education Savings Accounts?
According to estimates released by the Joint
Committee on Taxation, 14.3 million people would
take advantage of the accounts by the year 2002, and
10.8 million of those would be parents with children
in public schools. In addition, the committee found
that families with annual incomes of $75,000 or less
would receive 70 percent of the total tax benefit provided
by the accounts, while families making $50,000
or less would receive 46 percent of the tax benefit.
Senator Paul Coverdell (R-GA), who first proposed
education savings accounts, has pointed out
that if a parent were to place $2,000 each year in an
ESA starting in a child's first year, then, assuming a
7.5% interest rate, $14,488 would be available by the
first grade, $36,847 by the time the child starts junior
high school, and $46,732 when the child starts high
school. A family where each parent earns $35,000
annually could reduce its tax obligation by an estimated
$5,000 by the time the child reaches age 14.
Parents who were to use the accounts solely for
a child's higher education would benefit from the provision
that increases the annual allowable contribution
from $500 (the current maximum) to $2,000.
Groundswell of Popular Support
The 1998 Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup Annual Poll of
the Public's Attitudes Toward the Public Schools found
overwhelming public support for education savings
accounts. Sixty-eight percent of all respondents and
74 percent of public school parents support ESAs.
Encourages Investment in Education
Although the tax relief provided by edu-cation
savings accounts is rather nominal, it is
nonetheless significant in that it encourages parents
to invest in their children's education and attempts to
ease the burden they face with the costs of K-12 education.
The program is, after all, driven by the same
principles that drive tax relief to offset child-care
costs, college costs, and a host of other costs that
lawmakers consider when they try to equalize the tax
burden. According to the Congressional Research
Service, tax allowances for higher education alone
include the HOPE and Lifetime Learning credits, tax
deductions for student loan interest payments, and
tax incentives to encourage savings through college
IRAs, U.S. Savings Bonds, and state prepaid tuition
programs. Isn't it time for some form of assistance to
help parents with the costs of elementary and secondary
education?
Parent Assistance
It is hard to imagine a more fundamental obligation
for parents than that of directing the proper
upbringing of their children. Education savings
accounts would provide parents some practical assistance
with this awesome responsibility and would
encourage them, and others, to invest generously in
education.
Courtesy National Association of Independent Schools (NAIS). Visit
the NAIS web site at www.NAIS.org, which contains a searchable database of independent schools and hot links to school web pages.
For a list of member schools, call (202) 973-9743.
|