washingtonpost.com

Federal judge tosses Pa. child porn-blocking law

BC-Online Porn,0259

Federal judge tosses Pa. child porn-blocking law

PHILADELPHIA (AP) -- A federal judge threw out on Friday a Pennsylvania law requiring Internet service providers to block Web sites containing child pornography, saying the law was unconstitutional and cannot be enforced.

Enacted in 2002, the law gave Pennsylvania's attorney general the power to require that companies like America Online Inc. block customers from viewing Web sites that had been identified by the state as containing illegal content.

No one challenged the state's right to stop the distribution of child porn, which is already illegal under federal law, but lawyers for the Center for Democracy and Technology and the American Civil Liberties Union had argued that the technology used to block those Web sites was clumsy.

Over two years, the groups said, ISPs trying to obey blocking orders were forced to cut access to at least 1.5 million legal Web sites that had nothing to do with child pornography, but were part of the same Internet cluster as the offending sites.

Lawyers for the state said the technology exists for ISPs to block selectively and blamed Internet companies for not wanting to upgrade their systems.

U.S. District Judge Jan E. DuBois disagreed, saying current state of technology meant the law "cannot be implemented without excessive blocking of innocent speech in violation of the First Amendment."

-- -- --

On the Net:

Center for Democracy and Technology: http://www.cdt.org

AP-ES-09-10-04 1136EDT


© 2004 The Washington Post Company