A Good Run Spoiled
Smarty Jones's Triple Crown Bid Dashed by Birdstone at Belmont
By John Scheinman
Special to The Washington Post
Sunday, June 6, 2004; Page E01
ELMONT, N.Y., June 5 -- Smarty Jones took the Belmont Stakes by the throat coming out of the first turn, moving surprisingly early, as if he couldn't wait to run into history. But when the horse who looked like he might be the one to break the long drought between Triple Crown winners reached the home stretch, the finish line might as well have been miles away.
With a record crowd of 120,139 straining to see Smarty Jones do what five horses in the past seven years have failed to do -- become the first Triple Crown winner since Affirmed in 1978 -- Birdstone, a forgotten star from last year, ran down the Kentucky Derby and Preakness Stakes winner with a relentless drive to take the 1 1/2-mile Belmont Stakes.
Birdstone's victory, at odds of 36-1, gave New York-based trainer Nick Zito his first Belmont victory after 11 failed attempts.
The son of 1996 Kentucky Derby winner Grindstone beat Smarty Jones by a length, running the 1 1/2-mile race in 2 minutes 27.50 seconds. Zito's other runner in the race, Royal Assault, finished a distant third.
"As much as I hate to say it, what you just saw is one of the things that makes this game so great," said Smarty Jones's trainer, John Servis, who remained calm and gracious throughout the week as the pressure built.
As the post-race ceremony began in the winner's circle, Zito approached Servis, seemingly to congratulate him and apologize at the same time.
"He's a class guy," Zito said. "He brought this sport to where it should be. Smarty Jones will always be one of the most famous horses."
The race unfolded in a way that looked perfect for Smarty Jones. Coming out of the No. 9 post position on the far outside, jockey Stewart Elliott immediately put Smarty Jones into position, racing just off leader Purge and Rock Hard Ten as the field approached the first turn.
The two front-runners set a moderate opening quarter-mile of 24 1/5 seconds and a half-mile in 48 3/5 seconds.
In his victories in the Derby and Preakness, Smarty Jones relaxed kindly for Elliott, moving on pace-setter Lion Heart only when the jockey asked. But in the Belmont, Smarty Jones appeared keyed up. After the half-mile, he dragged the jockey to the lead, and there was still a mile to go.
"I had trouble getting him to settle," Elliott said afterward. "When I got him into the clear lead, I figured he might be able to relax."
Eddington, ridden by jockey Jerry Bailey, dogged Smarty Jones on his outside, while Rock Hard Ten, second in the Preakness, battled him on the inside.
A mile and a quarter into the race, Smarty Jones seized command and looked like a winner. He opened up by 3 1/2 lengths as Purge faded and Rock Hard Ten slowly tired out. Throughout the race, jockey Edgar Prado had kept Birdstone behind but in contact with the warring leaders up front. When the field moved off the far turn, Prado struck Birdstone twice with his whip and attacked.
Slowly, Birdstone began to cut into Smarty Jones's advantage. Elliott cracked Smarty Jones twice with his whip, peeked over his right shoulder and desperately rode for the wire.
© 2004 The Washington Post Company
__ Belmont Stakes __ • Smarty Jones found the final quarter-mile at the Belmont too much to handle.
• Smarty Jones fails in his bid to become the first Triple Crown winner since 1978.
• Birdstone ran down Smarty Jones to win the Belmont Stakes.
• Andrew Beyer: Did jockey Stewart Elliott makes his move too soon?
• Trainer John Servis showed no bitterness after Smarty Jones lost.
• Notebook: Birdstone jockey Edgar Prado apologized after winning the Beltmont Stakes.
__ The Field __ The field for Saturday's 136th Belmont Stakes, with post position, horse's name, jockey's name and odds:
1. Master David, Santos, 20-1
2. Purge, Velazquez, 5-1
3. Caiman, Dominguez, 50-1
4. Birdstone, Prado, 15-1
5. Rock Hard Ten, Solis, 8-1
6. Royal Assault, Day, 20-1
7. Tap Dancer, Castellano, 50-1
8. Eddington, Bailey, 10-1
9. Smarty Jones, Elliott, 2-5
• Trainers (by post position): 1, Bobby Frankel. 2, Todd Pletcher. 3, Angel Medina. 4, Nick Zito. 5, Jason Orman. 6, Nick Zito. 7, Ed Allard. 8, Mark Hennig. 9, John Servis.
__ How Smarty Are You? __ • Test your knowledge of Triple Crown trivia.
__ Quest for the Triple Crown __ • Preakness Stakes: Smarty Jones wins by a record 11½ lengths.
• Kentucky Derby: Smarty Jones becomes the first undefeated horse to win since Seattle Slew in 1977.