washingtonpost.com  > Politics > Elections > 2004 Election
Page 2 of 2  < Back  

Dementia and the Voter

"I have had caregivers accompany dementia patients into the booth and vote for them," said Jean Merget, a social worker at the North Broward Memory Disorder Center in Pompano Beach, Fla., who said she repeatedly heard of the practice during support group meetings. "This is not uncommon, especially in Florida."

Germaine L. Odenheimer, a neurologist and geriatrician, recalled seeing activists from the League of Women Voters coming through the VA nursing home in Gainesville, Fla., and registering residents to vote. "A large portion of the residents were demented," said Odenheimer, who now works at the University of Oklahoma. She said she asked activists from the nonpartisan group how they judged which patients were mentally competent. "I never had a satisfactory answer," she said.


Friday's Question:
It was not until the early 20th century that the Senate enacted rules allowing members to end filibusters and unlimited debate. How many votes were required to invoke cloture when the Senate first adopted the rule in 1917?
51
60
64
67


_____Message Boards_____
Post Your Comments

Many states do not bar people with dementia from voting unless they have been ruled unfit by court order -- a procedure rarely invoked. Some states automatically disenfranchise people who are under the care of a guardian, but such laws may be overly broad and unconstitutional. After the 2000 presidential election, for instance, disability rights advocates in Maine won a ruling that a law disenfranchising mentally ill voters under the care of a guardian was unconstitutional. Lawyer Kristin Aiello said the law also violated the Americans With Disabilities Act and federal civil rights laws barring discrimination.

"The difficulty is in drawing the line of who is entitled to vote and who is not," said Henderson, a professor of neurology at Stanford University. "Someone who is illiterate can vote. Someone who is intoxicated can vote. . . . It's easy to say people with dementia shouldn't vote, but once you look at the complexity of the issue, the solutions aren't easy."

Alzheimer's disease is characterized by memory loss, disorientation and problems with thinking. In advanced stages of dementia, patients can find it impossible to dress themselves, understand questions or even recognize loved ones. Sometimes, experts say, just asking patients if they want to vote can distinguish people who are competent from those who are not -- patients with severe dementia are usually not interested. It is their families and caregivers who understand the importance of the vote.

Without clear guidelines, however, poll workers and nursing home administrators are deciding which patients are competent to vote, but those decisions are not based on science. Widely used dementia tests provide scores indicating the degree of impairment but are not a reliable predictor of voting competence, experts say. Different people with the same scores may understand an election differently. A person's condition can change, so that a ruling of competence in April may not hold true in November.

"You want a cutoff point where you can say clearly there is so much impairment these people can't make a competent choice," said Brian R. Ott, a scientist at Brown University, "but we don't have a way of defining that cut point."

Ott surveyed 100 patients at a Rhode Island dementia clinic after the 2000 presidential election and found that 60 percent had voted. In another survey, Jason H.T. Karlawish and other researchers found that 64 percent of patients attending a dementia clinic in Pennsylvania had voted in the same election. While more severely impaired patients were less likely to vote, many with advanced Alzheimer's did vote. Ott found that 37 percent of patients with moderate dementia and about 18 percent with severe dementia had voted.

Neurologists are divided about how much help a spouse should offer a patient in voting: "Certainly it seems if I give my wife the right to make decisions about my health care -- keep him on life support or not -- you would think voting would be something she could do," said Ronald C. Petersen, director of the Mayo Clinic's Alzheimer's Disease Research Center in Rochester, Minn. At the same time, he said, it is reasonable to ask whether a person who had lost the ability to care for himself should also lose the ability to vote.

The Alzheimer's Association, a nonprofit science and advocacy group, receives calls every election season from families and nursing homes asking whether patients can vote. The answer is yes, said Stephen McConnell, senior vice president for advocacy and public policy at the association.

"Then they say, 'Can I vote for him?' " McConnell said. "We say, 'No, you can't vote for him. You can make decisions about his finances or health care or whether he should participate in research, but you can't vote for him.' " McConnell said a group of experts wrestled with the issue in August 2003 and agreed that patients even partly cognizant of the election should be allowed to vote.

As the baby boomers age, the number of Alzheimer's cases will soar, and experts said it is time for the nation to grapple with the issue -- if only to head off abuse.

Swerdloff said he wondered whether the Florida woman who voted for her demented husband was guilty of fraud. And he worried about activists going into nursing homes, where two-thirds of the residents have Alzheimer's disease.

"If they can go into a nursing home, why not go into an ICU and have a person who is comatose and on a ventilator -- let the caregiver vote," he said. "Then you say if a person is registered to vote, what about the brain-dead person?"

But Adam Butler of the Disability Rights Center in Little Rock said such talk holds people with disabilities to a higher standard than the rest of the population. No tests of mental competence are required to stand for office, and no law prevents "competent" voters from choosing candidates for questionable reasons: "People may vote because they like the way George W. Bush looks or because they like Heinz ketchup."


< Back  1 2

© 2004 The Washington Post Company