washingtonpost.com  > Arts & Living > Movies > DVD and Video Reviews
Bonus Points: DVD Reviews

The ♥ of 'Huckabees' on DVD

By Jen Chaney
washingtonpost.com Staff Writer
Tuesday, February 22, 2005;

"I ♥ Huckabees: Special Edition" (Rated R; List price: $39.98)
Release date: Feb. 22

Movies don't come much loopier than David O. Russell's "I ♥ Huckabees." With a plot that involves existential detectives and Eastern philosophy, "Huckabees" whirls wildly in comedic circles that can either frustrate or fascinate, depending on your perspective.

I Heart Huckabees
I Heart Huckabees
Jason Schwartzman and Jude Law butt heads in the loopy "I ♥ Huckabees." (Claudette Barius - AP)

_____More on DVDs_____
DVD Review: 'I Heart Huckabees'
DVD Review: 'Donnie Darko'
DVD Review: 'Miami Vice'
DVD Review: 'Ray'
Top Sellers of 2004
More DVD Reviews
List of Recent DVD Releases
List of What's Coming to DVD
_____Personal Tech_____
Home Entertainment Section: Reviews of TVs, DVD players and more

More literal-minded viewers may find themselves in the former category and probably won't care to delve more deeply into this special edition DVD's wealth of bonus features. But fans of the unusual and clearly gifted Russell (he also directed "Three Kings" and "Flirting With Disaster") may get a charge out of the production diary and other extras, which -- despite Russell's reputation for being difficult to work with -- reveal a breezy, often wacky on-set relationship between the filmmaker and his stellar cast.

This two-disc release of "Huckabees" includes enough supplemental material to fill a semester's worth of philosophy theses, certainly more than I can mention in this review. But the highlights include: 22 extended or deleted scenes; the aforementioned production diary; an outstanding episode of "The Charlie Rose Show," featuring Russell and stars Lily Tomlin and Dustin Hoffman; a bizarre half-hour infomercial hosted by the movie's existential detective team of Jaffe and Jaffe (played by Tomlin and Hoffman); outtakes; a gag reel (billed as "Miscellaneous Things People Did"); and two commentary tracks, one by Russell solo and one featuring the director and cast members Jason Schwartzman, Mark Wahlberg and Naomi Watts. The standard release only includes the commentary tracks, by the way, so you have to get this version if you want to check out the bulk of extras.

A lot of this stuff is hit or miss. And if you try to watch it all in one sitting, the overwhelming number of features will seem like overkill. Still, I have to credit Fox for giving this outside-the-mainstream movie, which drew mixed reviews and screened in limited theaters, such classy DVD treatment. (I particularly like the colorful menu screens, which mirror the design of the movie's posters.) Clearly there's hope that a cult following may build now that "Huckabees" is available on DVD. As a fan, I'd be happy to see that happen. As for the DVD itself, I wouldn't go so far as to say I ♥ it. But I certainly think this DVD provides plenty that's worth watching and worth pondering long after you hit "stop."

Most Unexpected Bonus Points: Some of the deleted scenes are dull but others serve up pleasant surprises, including cameo appearances by Mindy Cohn (Natalie of "Facts of Life" fame) and Charles Fleischer (the voice of Roger Rabbit and Carvelli from "Welcome Back, Kotter"). My personal favorite, though, is the last deleted scene, in which Schwartzman and Jude Law breakdance in the middle of the woods, using a piece of cardboard that just happens to be there. Truly, you haven't lived until you've heard Jude Law rap.

Bonus Point With Most Hollywood Credibility: The behind-the-scenes production diary features some bland moments, including Isabelle Huppert's incomprehensible attempt to explain the movie's meaning. But it's still worth checking out if only to hear director Spike Jonze, who films part of this doc, conducting interviews with the stars.

Most Skippable Bonus Point: The outtakes don't amount to much, unless you enjoy watching Wahlberg shove his fellow actors from a variety of angles.

Flat-Out Freakiest Bonus Point: It's hard to fully describe the half-hour infomercial that explores, as Tomlin's character puts it, "the neat, fun ways you can rip your soul open." But let's just say that it features interviews with two distinguished professors (one of whom is Columbia University's Robert Thurman, father of Uma and the inspiration for Hoffman's character in "Huckabees"); Tomlin perpetually knitting for no apparent reason; and everyone -- including Hoffman, Tomlin and the profs -- scooping out the innards of large watermelons and stuffing them in their mouths. If that doesn't make you want to watch, well, I don't know what will.

Coming in next week's "Bonus Points": A review of the platinum edition of "Bambi."

If you have feedback about "Bonus Points" or want to suggest a DVD for review, e-mail Jen Chaney.

© 2005 Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive