Interactive Gallery: Click here for photos, key stats and reviews of laptop models manufacturerd by Apple, Dell, Gateway, Hewlett-Packard, and Toshiba. Feature Story -- Muscle Power: Reporter Mike Musgrove looks at state of innovation (or lack thereof) in the laptop industry. Fast Forward -- The Rightness of Lightness: Columnist Rob Pegoraro wonders why manufacturers keep making laptops to be desktop replacements. Live Online -- Monday, 2 p.m. ET: Columnist Rob Pegoraro will be online to take your questions about this year's laptop shopping guide.
The small, 12.1-inch screen offered excellent off-axis visibility. There's a large touchpad and a decent but not great keyboard (it fell short of the smooth, authoritative feel of an IBM ThinkPad's). An Airport Extreme WiFi card is optional; the one included here worked flawlessly.
Setting up the iBook was straightforward, except that its registration sequence would not let me set it up and start working without entering personal information in a marketing-oriented questionnaire. I can opt out of receiving Apple's e-mails or phone calls, but I can't skip this questionnaire.
The iBook's default configuration is on the skimpy side, with a smaller hard drive than most machines and just 256 megabytes of memory.
A couple of other annoyances surfaced in day-to-day use: Its spiffy, slot-loading CD-RW/DVD drive frequently failed to eject a disc far enough for it be grabbed by its edges, and the charging indicator light often neglected to turn green when the battery was fully charged.
Then again, we didn't have to charge the battery too often. The iBook surpassed every other machine in this roundup, lasting 2 hours and 50 minutes at DVD playback, running 4:06 and 4:26 in our digital-music tests and an amazing 6 1/2 hours at its lowest power settings.
The software bundle, beyond the usual media applications of iPhoto and iTunes, included Quicken for Mac 2004 and the aging AppleWorks 6, which pleasantly surprised us by accurately reading current Microsoft Office files. That alone could be a real money-saver.
Tech support made us wait -- 10 to 15 minutes on two of three calls -- but was not only knowledgeable but friendly and willing to chat, a rarity these days.