washingtonpost.com  > Business > Industries > Financial Services

Quick Quotes

Report Slams Fannie Mae

U.S. Regulators Find Accounting Failures At Housing Financier

By David S. Hilzenrath
Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, September 23, 2004; Page A01

Fannie Mae, the giant mortgage finance company, has used improper accounting methods that raise serious questions about the quality of its management and the validity of its financial reports, government regulators reported yesterday.

Though it didn't quantify the effect of what it called pervasive misapplication of accounting rules on the company's books, the report by the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight cited one instance in 1998 where the company inappropriately deferred $200 million of estimated expenses, which enabled management to receive full annual bonuses. Had Fannie recorded the expenses in 1998, no bonus would have been paid, the report said.

_____FANNIE MAE_____
(FNM) Stock Quote and News
Historical Chart
Company Description
Analyst Ratings
_____Freddie Mac_____
(FRE) Stock Quote and News
Historical Chart
Company Description
Analyst Ratings
_____In Today's Post_____
Warnings Shadowed Firms' Rapid Growth (The Washington Post, Sep 23, 2004)
Probe Examining Fannie's Promises (The Washington Post, Sep 23, 2004)
_____Graphic_____
Falling Stock
_____On the Web_____
Statement by Ann McLaughlin Korologos -- Presiding Director, Fannie Mae Board of Directors
Fannie Mae Second Quarter 2004 Financial Information (pdf)
_____Primer_____
Freddie Mac Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae: Understanding the complexities of the organizations that help fund the nation's housing market
_____Related Articles_____
HUD Sets New Goals For Fannie, Freddie (The Washington Post, Nov 2, 2004)
Justice Probe of Freddie Mac Moving Slowly (The Washington Post, Nov 1, 2004)
Mortgage Regulator To Keep Agency Job (The Washington Post, Sep 16, 2004)
More Freddie Mac Articles
_____Fannie Mae_____
News/Stock Quotes
Charts
_____Related Coverage_____
Futures of Fannie's CEO, CFO Unclear As Directors Meet (The Washington Post, Dec 17, 2004)
Banks Scrutinize Their Accounting (The Washington Post, Dec 17, 2004)
Fannie Took the Shortcut (The Washington Post, Dec 16, 2004)
SEC Tells Fannie Mae To Restate Earnings (The Washington Post, Dec 16, 2004)
More

The report also detailed numerous transactions over several years where it said Fannie Mae management intentionally smoothed out gyrations in its earnings to show investors it was a low-risk company. Fannie "maintained a corporate culture that emphasized stable earnings at the expense of accurate financial disclosures," regulators said in a letter to the company.

Chief executive Franklin D. Raines and the board of directors were not singled out for blame, but the report criticized "a culture and environment that made these problems possible." It did name J. Timothy Howard, the company's vice chairman and chief financial officer, saying he "failed to provide adequate oversight" of key control and reporting functions and had jobs in which he both set earnings targets and then the accounting policies that could be used to meet them.

The report said company management didn't adequately investigate allegations of irregularities by a former employee, Roger Barnes, who couldn't be reached for comment last night. It said his concerns were "substantive" and his cooperation with regulators important to their examination.

The findings echo those made last year about Freddie Mac, the other large government-chartered mortgage finance company. Regulators, who launched their Fannie Mae inquiry after the Freddie Mac problems came to light, found that Fannie failed to follow the rules in accounting for complex financial instruments known as derivatives, which the company uses to hedge against movements in interest rates. Much of rival Freddie Mac's accounting problems involved accounting for derivatives.

That probe resulted in a $125 million fine and a management shake-up at Freddie Mac.

The two companies were chartered by the government to provide a steady flow of funds for home mortgages. To do that, they borrow money from investors and buy mortgages from banks and other lenders. They also package mortgages into securities for sale to investors. Together they help finance half the home mortgages in the country.

The report's findings that Fannie lacks sufficient internal controls and that its accounting policymaking is "dysfunctional" added to the regulators' concern about the company's safety and soundness.

Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan and Treasury Secretary John W. Snow have called for tougher oversight of Fannie and Freddie because they worry that, given the huge scale of their operations, serious financial troubles at the companies could put nation's financial system at risk. Though the government disavows any responsibility for the companies' debts, public and private analysts say the government could be called upon to bail them out in a crunch.


CONTINUED    1 2    Next >

© 2004 The Washington Post Company