washingtonpost.com  > Metro > Special Reports > Wilson Bridge

Dangerous Debris, on the Road Again and Again

By C. Woodrow Irvin
Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, September 9, 2004; Page VA20

After 11 years with the Virginia Department of Transportation's safety service patrol, Mike Karbonski can only shake his head at some of the things he sees that have dropped off vehicles on Northern Virginia's highways.

One recent afternoon, a garbage truck heading south on Shirley Highway spilled cardboard across the right two lanes, prompting Karbonski to call in a front loader to clean it up before rush hour. A few weeks earlier, a fallen L-shaped angle iron caused flat tires on six vehicles near Telegraph Road and Route 1 (Richmond Highway). The day after that, a mattress fell off a vehicle at the Capital Beltway and Interstate 66, striking a car and bursting into flames.

Workers shovel debris after a garbage truck traveling spilled part of its load on Shirley Highway, blocking the two right lanes. Officials say falling debris is an increasing hazard on Northern Virginia's roadways. (Michael Temchine - For The Washington Post)

Highlights From a AAA Safety Report

• Fallen cargo, wheel separations and other highway debris likely cause more than 25,000 crashes a year and on average kill between 80 and 90 people annually. Although these accidents make up less than 1 percent of all crashes in the United States and Canada, it is worthwhile examining whether they can be reduced.

• Poor tire maintenance, especially underinflation, is the largest cause of tire debris on U.S. and Canadian roads.

• Loads carried on short trips -- taking a Christmas tree or a new mattress home -- concern safety specialists, who say people are less likely to pay attention to securing the load if they are traveling a short distance.

• Most fatal crashes involving roadway debris occur during the daytime on major roads with a speed limit of 55 mph or higher. By contrast, about half of other fatal crashes happen at night on major roads where the speed limit is less than 55 mph.

• Heavy or medium trucks make up 9 percent of the vehicles involved in all fatal crashes, compared with 27 percent of vehicles involved in fatal debris- related crashes.

• About a quarter of the trucks that authorities stop for suspected safety violations are taken out of service or impounded for violations, many of them for underinflated or worn tires. Periodic vehicle safety inspections are mandatory for private and commercial vehicles.

• The rougher the pavement, the more likely it is that there will be a crash involving debris from a vehicle that has lost its load.

Source: AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety, "The Safety Impact of Vehicle-Related Road Debris," June 2004.

Panel To Seek Funding For Metro (The Washington Post, Sep 9, 2004)
D.C. Area Traffic Heavier, Costlier (The Washington Post, Sep 8, 2004)
Metro to Prepare Riders for Terror (The Washington Post, Sep 2, 2004)
I-66 Work Begins to Add Four Lanes Near Manassas (The Washington Post, Aug 31, 2004)
More Stories

"The guy ran over the mattress, and it hung underneath," Karbonski said. "The catalytic converter and the muffler caught the mattress on fire."

Karbonski's supervisor, Chris Landis, said such road debris from cars and trucks "causes mayhem. If traffic is heavy, people are usually driving a little closer to each other than they should be, and a car in front of you will suddenly swerve out of the way [to avoid the debris]. Suddenly there is something in front of you, and you have to swerve out of the way. If there is someone on either side of you, it's an accident."

Cargo or vehicle parts that accidentally fall off cars and trucks are an increasing hazard on Northern Virginia's crowded roadways, according to traffic safety officials. Though most such debris is from passenger vehicles, the materials that drop from trucks often are the most visible to motorists. Nearly 16 years after the state began requiring trucks to cover their loads, many still spill gravel, sand, trash and building materials onto area roadways, sometimes with frightening consequences.

Stuart Roy's friends often introduce him as 'the guy who almost got killed by a flying pitchfork.' Last November, Roy was heading east on the Woodrow Wilson Bridge in a sport-utility vehicle when a pitchfork from a westbound dump truck hurtled through the SUV's windshield, stopping inches from Roy's chest. The pitchfork now is mounted on wood and displayed on a wall in Roy's Alexandria home, a reminder of his close call.

About 25,000 crashes and 90 deaths a year are caused by vehicle parts or cargo that are unintentionally discharged onto roadways in the United States and Canada, according to a report released in June by the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety. Many of those accidents are preventable, foundation officials said, because they are the result of poorly maintained tires.

"Blown tires, tire treads, drive shafts, bumpers, hoods, leaf springs, and brake parts have all contributed to serious crashes," said the report, which did not have local statistics. "At highway speeds, even small debris can be deadly. Items such as hand tools, spare tires, tarps, and tie-down straps can pose a serious danger if they land on a congested highway."

Safety specialists said they fear the problem is getting worse in the Washington region, especially in growing areas such as Fairfax and Loudoun counties, where intense construction activity is underway to build the homes, schools, shopping centers, roads and other structures needed to serve an expanding population.

The mammoth projects to untangle the Springfield Mixing Bowl and replace the Woodrow Wilson Bridge involve hundreds of construction vehicles, some of which do not completely secure their loads.

Cruising along the Beltway one recent evening during rush hour, VDOT road safety patrolman David Bennett pointed out a dump truck to a reporter. A large mound of dirt was visible above the truck's cargo area, and a tarp covering the load was fluttering loosely.

"He doesn't have it covered properly," Bennett said, continuing with this possible scenario: "A big chunk of dirt comes out, somebody is following too close, it hits their windshield, they swerve not knowing what happened and hit somebody else."

Trucks carrying materials such as gravel and dirt must be covered by a secured tarp, according to state law, or face fines ranging from $30 to $500. Leslie L. Byrne, a former Democratic state senator from Fairfax who sponsored the covered trucks measure when she was in office, said for the most part the law has reduced the amount of litter on state roads.

However, she said, "There has been spotty enforcement. The condition of a lot of these tarps is problematic. Some of them have such gaping holes in them that [the drivers] might as well not use them." She added, "The commercial vehicles that carry garbage, construction debris and landscaping debris -- that's the mainstay of the problem."

CONTINUED    1 2 3    Next >

© 2004 The Washington Post Company