washingtonpost.com  > World > Middle East > Near East > Gaza Strip West Bank

Arab Leaders As Divided On Arafat Dead as Alive

Six to Attend Cairo Ceremony; More Have Remained Silent

By Scott Wilson
Washington Post Foreign Service
Friday, November 12, 2004; Page A15

CAIRO, Nov. 11 -- The body of Yasser Arafat arrived in the Egyptian capital Thursday night for a memorial service to be attended by a group of men he managed to inspire and antagonize over decades of tireless public diplomacy: his fellow Arab leaders.

The heads of seven Arab countries will gather Friday morning at a military club here to pay tribute to a former guerrilla leader who cajoled, criticized and counted on them during his four-decade effort to create a Palestinian state, a cause that often united the Arab world. But at least as many Arab nations will not send heads of state, underscoring the contentious relationship many of them had with Arafat.


Workers pray at the King Faisal mosque in Cairo, the city where Yasser Arafat was born and where a memorial service was to be held for him Friday. (Petr Josek -- Reuters)

__ ARAFAT REMEMBERED __
spacer
Photo Gallery Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat was laid to rest after memorials in Cairo and Ramallah.
spacer
Video: Thousands Greet Arafat's Coffin in Ramallah
Video: Arafat's Funeral in Cairo
Narrated Slide Show: Arafat's Life
Timeline: The Life of Arafat
Photo Gallery: Palestinians Mourn
spacer
__ Live Discussions __
Transcript: Raghida Dergham, senior diplomatic correspondent for Al Hayat
Transcript: Henry Siegman
Transcript: Fawas Gerges
spacer
__ Special Report __
Yasser Arafat, 1929-2004
Full coverage, more features.

___Conflict in the Mideast ___
SPECIAL REPORT
spacer
Latest News From the Mideast:


Full Mideast Coverage
spacer
Graphic:
One Land, Two Peoples: A look at the history of the conflict between Palestinian Arabs and Jews.
spacer
Special Report:
Defining the Barrier: A series of multimedia reports examining Israel's controversial building of a security fence to separate it from adjacent Palestinian areas.

___ Postwar Iraq ___

_____ Request for Photos_____

Duty In Iraq
We want to give you the opportunity to show firsthand what it is like to live and work in Iraq.


_____ Latest News _____
spacer
More Coverage
spacer
_____ U.S. Military Deaths _____

Faces of the Fallen
Portraits of U.S. service members who have died in Iraq since the beginning of the war.


Over the years, such Persian Gulf states as Kuwait gave millions of dollars to Arafat's cause, only to have him side with Saddam Hussein after Iraq invaded Kuwait in 1990. Lebanon and Jordan provided refuge for his exiled Palestine Liberation Organization in the 1970s and '80s before turning against Arafat's militants in bloody conflicts for fear they were undermining state authority. Syria, a champion of Arab nationalism, sent troops to Lebanon to battle the PLO.

Arafat had his own leverage: the popularity of his cause among millions of disaffected Arabs across the region. The threat this represented was enough to win him refuge and resources from many Arab leaders, whose political standing at home benefited from their association with the Palestinian liberation movement. But their support was quickly withdrawn when it clashed with their overriding concern of maintaining domestic stability, and Arafat eventually overshadowed and outlived some of his fiercest Arab rivals.

"His relationship to other Arab leaders was extremely ambivalent," said Mohamed Said, deputy director of the Al-Ahram Center for Political and Strategic Studies in Cairo. "On the one hand, most Arab leaders have argued strongly with Arafat. On the other, they have accepted him as the golden mean within the Palestinian movement. He was never seen as someone they could sideline, ignore or upset."

Those mixed feelings were evident across the region Thursday as some leaders expressed their condolences following his death while others reserved judgment for hours after it was announced. Egypt's president, Hosni Mubarak, called Arafat a "historic leader," while King Fahd of Saudi Arabia said he shared the pain of the Palestinian people. Jordan's King Abdullah called his death a tragedy, and several Arab states declared an official period of mourning.

But other prominent Arab leaders, most notably Bashar Assad, the president of Syria, remained silent. Of the Arab countries, only the heads of state of Yemen, Egypt, Jordan, Tunisia, Sudan and Algeria had announced by late Thursday that they would attend the memorial service. Saudi Arabia's acting leader, Crown Prince Abdullah, will attend. The Lebanese president, Emile Lahoud, a Maronite Christian, will also fly in. But the leaders of Syria and Libya had not disclosed whether they would pay tribute to Arafat in person or send a proxy.

Since emerging in the mid-1960s as the face of the Palestinian movement, Arafat benefited enormously from military, economic and political support extended by various Arab leaders. But waging a guerrilla war against Israel from foreign countries put Arafat in constant conflict with his donors and hosts, whose views on the eventual shape of a Palestinian state and the tactics to achieve it often clashed with his own.

After the 1967 war, thousands of Palestinian refugees flooded camps east of the Jordan River and in southern Lebanon, where many of them remain and demonstrated in small groups Thursday to mourn Arafat's death. Palestinian refugees were welcomed by Jordan, but the late King Hussein, the father of the current monarch, moved against them in 1970 at a time when their numbers and militancy posed a risk to his rule. The king's eventual move to establish diplomatic relations with Israel in 1994 was criticized by Arafat.

In the mid-1970s, Arafat's PLO was a source of concern in Lebanon, where it had taken refuge after fleeing Jordan. Hafez Assad, the Syrian president, sent thousands of troops into Lebanon in 1976 at the request of the allied Christian government to put down the PLO, a clash that helped fuel what would be a nearly 15-year civil war. Bashar Assad, who became president on his father's death in 2000, had not sent a message of condolence hours after Arafat's death was announced.

The oil boom of the 1970s brought Arafat hundreds of millions of dollars a year from the Gulf states, especially Saudi Arabia, which gave tens of millions a year to the Palestinian cause. Kuwait, which welcomed many Palestinian refugees as manual laborers and engineers, also contributed oil proceeds to the cause.

But in a move that angered many Arab nations, including his most generous donors, Arafat sided with Saddam Hussein during the 1991 Persian Gulf War, waged to drive Iraqi forces from Kuwait. Kuwait never forgave Arafat for supporting Hussein, a generous supporter of the Palestinian cause in his own right, and the principality had not sent official condolences on his death by late Thursday.

Mubarak, a frequent mediator between Israel and Arafat, also fought bitterly with Arafat at times, mostly over his refusal to accept peace agreements put forward by Israel and the United States. Mubarak encouraged Arafat to accept the August 2000 proposal outlined at Camp David and sweetened a few months later at a conference in Taba on Egypt's Sinai coast.

Arafat won popularity at home for what was seen as a refusal to compromise on the return of all the West Bank and the right of Palestinian refugees to reclaim land lost in Israel's war for independence in 1948. But his stance angered Mubarak and U.S. officials, who believed he had failed to seize his best chance for peace.

"The Arab leaders stood by him politically, militarily and economically," said Abdelraouf Elreedy, chairman of the Egyptian Council on Foreign Relations and a former ambassador to Washington. "The problem is that the Palestinian problem itself is a most oblique problem, and the definition of the national project has gone through so many phases."

Elreedy, who was a member of the Egyptian delegation that negotiated the Camp David accords with Israel in the late 1970s, said Arab leaders often found themselves in a weaker position than Arafat because of the popularity of his cause on the Arab street. As a result, even the most powerful Arab leaders failed to push Arafat toward peace agreements that to many of them appeared fair or at least the best that could be achieved.

"There has been friction and contradiction between their objectives," Elreedy said. "The Arabs did not feel they were in a position to pressure the Palestinians to accept any offer for fear they'd be accused of selling out the Palestinian cause."


© 2004 The Washington Post Company