washingtonpost.com  > Technology > Personal Tech > Reviews

Quick Quotes

M:robe Tries to Do Too Much

Player-Viewer-Camera Is Great Concept With So-So Results

By Tracey Capen
PC World
Tuesday, March 1, 2005

Combine a small hard drive, good-sized LCD, and built-in digital camera and you might have the ultimate portable multimedia box. Pint-size audio players and photo viewers abound, but Olympus' $500 M:robe 500i is the only player I've seen to add a digital camera to the mix. I have to give Olympus credit for a great concept, but I think it's a hat trick the company did not quite pull off.

I tested a shipping version of the (just) pocketable device, which plays WMA and MP3 music files, lets you view photos on its 3.7-inch color screen, and has a built-in 1.2-megapixel camera for taking spur-of-the-moment snapshots. As a music player, the 4.3-by-.8-by 2.9-inch M:robe is a little bulky, especially compared to other hard drive-based players like the ubiquitous IPod.

m:robe
m:robe
Operating the M:robe is easy enough. Aside from the power switch, everything is handled with touch-screen menus. In use, however, changing settings and switching between music and photo modes seems slow. (Courtesy Mullen Public Relations)

_____Recent Reviews_____
DVD on the Edge (PC World Communications, Inc. All rights reserved. , Mar 16, 2005)
First Night: Round 2; Champions: Return to Arms; Saint Paint Studio 9.2 (The Washington Post, Mar 13, 2005)
Real-Time Armor for the Road Warrior (The Washington Post, Mar 13, 2005)
Intel Revs Centrino Notebooks (PC World Communications, Inc. All rights reserved. , Mar 10, 2005)
_____Personal Tech_____
Full Section
Fast Forward
Web Watch
Help File
Reviews
___Personal Tech E-letter___
Washington Post personal technology columnist Rob Pegoraro answers reader e-mail and expands on themes he touches on in his weekly newspaper column. The e-mail version of this weekly feature includes links to the latest gadget and software reviews.
Click Here for Free Sign-up
Read E-letter Archive


The quality of the audio was about par for small players I've listened to, and the M:robe does come with an in-line remote control for the headphones, which makes stashing the device in a bag more practical. One nice feature: you can quickly add a current cut to a "Favorites" list by touching a heart-shaped icon on the screen.

So-So Photos

Digital photos I transferred to the M:robe looked pretty good on the device's 640-by-480-pixel screen, but shots I took with the built-in camera are about what you'd expect from a cell-phone camera.

Taking photos could not be easier: just view the scene on the LCD and touch the screen. But colors in the resulting shots looked a bit flat and darker than I'd like (you really need a good light source).

You also have few options when using the camera: no exposure control of any sort; no digital zoom; no flash, though there is a single illumination LED next to the lens. The M:robe supports PictBridge, which lets you connect it to a compatible printer and print photos without a PC. This worked with an HP printer I have, but not especially smoothly.

In this multimedia age, combining photos with music is an attractive concept, and the M:robe lets you do this with its Remix function. The feature lets you attach one music file to a collection of photos, allowing you to create simple slide shows with audio. Making Remix Cubes, as Olympus calls each photo/music set, is easy once you get the hang of it (although I had to consult the manual the first time).

Touchy Interface

Operating the M:robe is easy enough. The only button is the on/off switch--everything else is handled by touching the screen and working though the fairly simple menu system.

In use, however, changing the M:robe setting and switching between music and photo modes seemed slow. There was usually a noticeable delay as the M:robe accessed its hard drive and responded to a menu selection.

I had no complaints on battery life: I got about 2.5 hours playing both audio and a slide show continuously. With the LCD off and playing just music, the M:robe lasted just over 8.5 hours

Loading and synchronizing photos and music is handled with the M:trip software and the unit's included cradle (which you must use to connect the M:robe to a PC and to charge its fixed lithium battery).

M:trip looks and functions much like Apple's iTunes, though with added controls for managing photos. It works well enough as a jukebox and photo viewer, and it rips CDs to Microsoft's WMA format. (If you want to rip MP3s, you'll need another app.)

After playing with the M:robe, there were a couple of additional features I wish it had. Since it's a nice photo viewer and has 20GB of storage, I really wish it would connect directly to my digital camera for downloading images. A media slot would also have been a nice addition.


© 2005 PC World Communications, Inc. All rights reserved.