washingtonpost.com  > Business > Columnists > The Regulators

OSHA Slow to Act on Beryllium Exposure, Critic Says

By Cindy Skrzycki
Tuesday, February 1, 2005; Page E01

For several years, Adam M. Finkel, a top administrator at the Labor Department's Occupational Safety and Health Administration, said he expected the agency to test its inspectors for exposure to beryllium fumes or dust. In 2002, he realized the agency was not moving in that direction, and he became a whistle-blower.

He said he thought inspectors were at risk for contracting chronic beryllium disease, which can be fatal. The agency didn't begin testing until last year. And recent news reports said at least three inspectors tested positive for blood abnormalities that indicate they could be susceptible to the disease.

_____Previous Columns_____
Report Sheds Light on Changing Role of Regulation (The Washington Post, Jan 25, 2005)
Medicare Reconsiders Claims Criteria for Wheelchairs (The Washington Post, Jan 18, 2005)
Small-Business Advocate Plays Big Role in Rulemaking (The Washington Post, Jan 11, 2005)
A Gutsy David Takes On a Goliath (The Washington Post, Dec 28, 2004)
More past columns
_____Regulations on the Web_____
Government Printing Office provides the text of rules.
The Federal Register lists new rules and proposals daily.
The General Accounting Office offers cost-benefit analyses of major rules.
OMB Watch is a public interest group that monitors the Office of Management and Budget.
The Mercatus Center at George Mason University provides conservative analysis of rules.
Regulation.org is the conservative Heritage Foundation's rules site.
The AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies offers scholary rules analysis, including its $100 Million Club.

Jonathan L. Snare, acting administrator at OSHA, said in an interview that it would be premature to comment on whether anyone tested positive because the agency has not completed the testing of 301 inspectors.

Beryllium, an extremely lightweight metal that is a carcinogen, is used in making microprocessors, golf clubs and dental alloys and in the military and nuclear industry.

Inhaling even minute amounts of beryllium dust or fumes can be dangerous, though not everyone exposed gets sick. Studies cited by OSHA show that an average of 2 percent to a high of 15 percent of workers who manufacture beryllium products get the disease.

The permissible exposure level for beryllium is 2 micrograms per cubic meter of air for an eight-hour period. That limit was set in 1971 and was based on a 1949 standard set by the Atomic Energy Commission. OSHA began work on setting a new standard in 1975, but it was never completed.

"The agency is in some kind of grand denial of the problem that extends to its own workers. Because they have not protected workers, they have put their own employees at risk," said Peter Lurie, a physician and deputy director of Public Citizen's Health Research Group.

In 1999, the Department of Energy cut the standard for beryllium exposure for workers at its plants to 0.2 micrograms per cubic meter of air and started a prevention and testing program for current and former workers. Finkel said medical and scientific staff members at OSHA tried to persuade their agency to do the same.

At the time, Finkel was a director of health standards for the entire agency. He later became a regional administrator in Denver.

He said in the interview that he based his concerns on data that showed possible exposure levels for up to 500 inspectors. Workers who show a sensitivity to the metal should not be further exposed, Finkel said, noting that he was speaking for himself and not the agency. "It's analogous to sending a kid with peanut allergy into the Jiffy factory."

CONTINUED    1 2    Next >

© 2005 The Washington Post Company