washingtonpost.com  > Nation > Search the States > Massachusetts

Man Charged In Cape Cod Woman's Death

Suspect Volunteered DNA That Led to Murder Arrest

By Jonathan Finer
Washington Post Staff Writer
Saturday, April 16, 2005; Page A03

BOSTON, April 15 -- After more than three years of frustration, false leads and a controversial dragnet for DNA evidence, prosecutors announced Friday that police have arrested a suspect in the slaying of fashion writer Christa Worthington on Cape Cod.

Christopher McCowen, 33, of Hyannis, Mass., was arrested Thursday evening and is accused of fatally stabbing Worthington in the sleepy town of Truro. He pleaded not guilty to murder, aggravated rape and armed assault Friday in Orleans District Court.

Christopher McCowen is led by police in South Yarmouth, Mass. He collected trash at the victim's home. (Steve Heaslip -- Cape Cod Times Via AP)

Authorities determined last week that DNA willingly provided by McCowen more than a year ago matched evidence found at the crime scene. District Attorney Michael O'Keefe said in a news conference that at the time of the killing, McCowen was a trash collector who made pickups at Worthington's home.

"There is no evidence whatsoever to suggest there was any relationship whatsoever between them, other than him walking up her driveway to collect her trash," he added.

Jan Worthington, the victim's cousin, told the Associated Press outside the courtroom that "we're happy there's been an arrest" but added that "it's a sad day as well."

Worthington, 46, was found dead on Jan. 6, 2002, her daughter Ava, 2, covered with blood but unharmed at her side. The case, which spawned the first homicide investigation in Truro since 1968, attracted widespread media attention and was the subject of a best-selling book, "Invisible Eden."

Authorities began gathering DNA evidence from the start of their investigation and used it to exonerate several of Worthington's close acquaintances.

Among those who initially drew suspicion were a former boyfriend, who discovered Worthington's body in her home, and another local man who is Ava's father.

The case went unsolved, despite a $25,000 reward offered by Worthington's friends and family. Then, in January, investigators asked every man in Truro, which has a population of about 2,000, to voluntarily provide DNA samples, obtained by wiping a cotton swab on the inside of the cheek.

At least 75 men agreed on the first day of the sweep, but the tactic drew criticism from the American Civil Liberties Union and other privacy rights advocates.

O'Keefe said McCowen had been asked to provide a DNA sample four months after the killing, along with others who had business at Worthington's home.

He agreed, but he did not give police the sample until March 2004. It was not until April 7 of this year that state police forensic scientists determined that his sample implicated him in the crime.

"It's a question of the resources that the lab has to work with," O'Keefe replied when asked why it took more than a year to process the results. "You're asking the crime lab to work those into the rotation of current cases that they're doing all the time with very few resources."

Public records show that McCowen, who moved to Massachusetts from Florida in the mid-1990s, has a long criminal record, including prison terms for burglary, motor vehicle theft and trafficking in stolen goods.

The Cape Cod Times reported Friday that more than one local woman had filed a restraining order against him in recent years.

McCowen's attorney, Francis O'Boy, did not return a telephone call seeking comment Friday.

O'Keefe acknowledged Friday that law enforcement officials were fortunate McCowen had agreed to provide the DNA sample and had not fled the area.

Wendy Murphy, a former assistant district attorney who now teaches a course on sexual violence at New England School of Law, said that investigations can be compromised by lengthy delays in processing forensic evidence.

"There was a time in Massachusetts when it was almost a comedy, you knew you would have at least a six-month time lag because of how backed up the system was," she said. "Delay is always strategically advantageous to the accused. Evidence gets lost or tainted. Victims and witnesses get frustrated, or die, or move away. They got a real break that this guy was still around when they found a match."

Worthington had covered the fashion industry throughout Europe for several magazines, including Elle, Women's Wear Daily and Cosmopolitan. In 1998, she moved from New York to Cape Cod, where she had spent summers as a child.

Researcher Meg Smith in Washington contributed to this report.

© 2005 The Washington Post Company