washingtonpost.com  > Sports > Leagues and Sports > Horse Racing

It's Smarty's Party

Philadelphia Star Rallies to Remain Undefeated and Earn $5 Million Prize

By John Scheinman
Special to The Washington Post
Sunday, May 2, 2004; Page E01

LOUISVILLE, May 1 -- Smarty Jones came to Churchill Downs with a great story; he left Saturday with a garland of roses draped across his neck.

With a powerful surge heading into the far turn, the Philadelphia Park-based colt separated from a pack of stalkers, lit out after runaway leader Lion Heart and ran him down in the stretch to take the 130th Kentucky Derby on a sloppy track.

Smarty Jones, left, with jockey Stewart Elliott aboard, drives toward a 23/4-length victory over Lion Heart on muddy Churchill Downs track. (Al Behrman -- AP)

_____ Kentucky Derby _____
 Ky Derby
Andrew Beyer: Thoroughbred racing has a bright new star.
Smarty Jones becomes the first undefeated horse to win the Kentucky Derby since Seattle Slew in 1977.
William Gildea: The Kentucky Derby used to be the bluebloods' race, but for the last two years it's been the blue-collar special.
Jockey Stewart Elliott's decision to return to racing paid off as he won the sport's biggest prize Saturday.
Notebook: Tapit trainer Michael Dickinson said his horse didn't like running in the mud.
Audio Slideshow

_____ Live Online _____
Post columnist Andrew Beyer was online Friday. Read the transcript.
Analyst Jill Byrne of TVG interactive horse racing network was online Friday. Read the transcript.
Kate Davis, the director of the documentary "Jockey," was online Tuesday. Read the transcript.

_____ Post Position, Odds _____
Field for Saturday's 130th Kentucky Derby, with post position, horse's name, jockey's name and odds:

1. Limehouse, Santos, 38-1
2. Song of the Sword, Arroyo Jr., 57-1
3. Lion Heart, Smith, 9-1
4. Action This Day, Flores, 42-1
5. Wimbledon -- Scratch
6. Friends Lake, Migliore, 17-1
7. Minister Eric, Day, 12-1
8. Master David, Solis, 8-1
9. St Averil -- Scratch
10. Imperialism, Desormeaux, 9-1
11. The Cliff's Edge, Sellers, 8-1
12. Borrego, Espinoza, 9-1
13. Birdstone, Prado, 15-1
14. Read The Footnotes, Albarado, 20-1
15. Smarty Jones, Elliott, 5-1
16. Castledale, Valdivia, 27-1
17. Pollard's Vision, Velazquez, 33-1
18. Tapit, Dominguez, 5-1
19. Pro Prado, McKee, 65-1
20. Quintons Gold Rush, Nakatani, 58-1

Trainers (by post position): 1, Todd Pletcher. 2, Jennifer Pedersen. 3, Patrick Binacone. 4, Dick Mandella. 5, Bob Baffert. 6, John Kimmel. 7, Dick Mandella. 8, Bobby Frankel. 9, Rafael Becerra. 10, Kristin Mulhall. 11, Nick Zito. 12, Beau Greely. 13, Nick Zito. 14, Rick Violette. 15, John Servis. 16, Jeff Mullins. 17, Todd Pletcher. 18, Michael Dickinson. 19, Bob Holthus. 20, Steve Asmussen.

Owners (by post position): 1, Dogwood Stable. 2, Paraneck Stable. 3, Derrick Smith and Michael Tabor. 4, B.W. Hughes. 5, James McIngvale. 6, Chester & Mary Browman. 7, Diamond A Racing Corporation. 8, Georgica Stable, Stephen Mack and Andrew Rosen. 9, Stan Fulton. 10, Steve Taub. 11, Robert LaPenta. 12, Jon Kelly, Ralls & Foster LLC, Brad Scott, Et Al. 13, Marylou Whitney Stables. 14, Klaravich Stables Inc. 15, Someday Farm. 16, Frank Lyons and Greg Knee. 17, Edgewood Farm. 18, Winchell Thoroughbreds LLC. 19, Mrs. James Winn. 20, Padua Stables and Jay Manoogian.

Weights: 126 pounds. Purse: $1,214,800 if 20 start. First place: $914,800. Second place: $170,000. Third place: $85,000. Fourth place: $45,000.

The 23/4 -length victory, before 140,054, capped as unlikely a progression to glory in America's signature horse race as Funny Cide produced the year before. Born at his owners' Someday Farm just outside of Philadelphia, Smarty Jones was one of two horses Roy and Pat Chapman did not sell as they planned to get out of the racing business in 2001. Now, he is the first undefeated horse to win the Kentucky Derby since Seattle Slew in 1977.

"My wife calls us backyarders," said Roy Chapman, 77, as he sat in a wheelchair, breathing oxygen through a tank because he suffers from chronic asthma and emphysema. "I call us ham-and-eggers. We've had a lot of claimers, but we've had a lot of fun. We never expected to get here."

Unbeaten in six starts, Smarty Jones went off the tepid 4-to-1 favorite in the 18-horse field. He won the 1¼-mile Derby in a slow 2 minutes 4.06 seconds on a very unstable track.

With the victory, Smarty Jones collected a windfall $5,854,800 for his connections, the largest single payoff in horse racing history. The extra $5 million came courtesy of a bonus offered by Oaklawn Park to any horse who could sweep the Southwest Stakes, the Rebel and the Arkansas Derby and then go on to win in Kentucky.

The Kentucky Derby this year looked as wide open as any in memory, with no standout runner and an intriguing mix of speed horses, stalkers and closers. With the sharp, controlling speed of Lion Heart, who had showed tenacity in finishing second in his two prep races for the Derby, and the superior stalking ability of Smarty Jones, the closers never got into the mix. Many struggled in the slop just to get around the track.

Tapit, the Maryland-based runner trained by Michael Dickinson and ridden by leading mid-Atlantic jockey Ramon Dominguez, passed a string of horses on the backside but faded to ninth. Morning-line favorite The Cliff's Edge, the Blue Grass Stakes winner, lumbered up to finish a non-threatening fifth.

Speed dominated.

When the gate opened, Lion Heart, ridden by veteran Mike Smith, went right to the front. Six runners lined up behind him, Smarty Jones among them, jostling for position going into the first turn.

"He was inside and I was looking to get him clear sailing," said jockey Stewart Elliott, a 39-year-old journeyman rider who won the Kentucky Derby in his first try. "When I got the chance to get clear, I took it."

On the backside of the track after a half-mile in 46.73 seconds, Smarty Jones, one-eyed runner Pollard's Vision and Quintons Gold Rush emerged as the main challengers. Unlike the winner, however, those two runners could not sustain their bids, wilting in the late stages of the race.

"On the backstretch he was going really nice," Quintons Gold Rush's jockey Corey Nakatani said. "I really don't know what happened."

As Lion Heart reached the three-eighths pole, he looked comfortable and a threat to beat the field wire-to-wire. Smith said, "He left [the gate] quickly and did relax, but the crowd got to screaming and he got into the bridle."

CONTINUED    1 2    Next >

© 2004 The Washington Post Company