washingtonpost.com  > Sports > Columnists > Norman Chad

NBA: No Boys Allowed?

By Norman Chad
Monday, April 18, 2005; Page D02

David Stern wants to raise the NBA age minimum to 20. I'd like to raise the age minimum of someone taking my order at Taco Bell to 25.

(Think about it, folks: How much responsibility do you need to sit at the end of the Clippers' bench for three years? You pretty much just have to remember which locker you left your Nikes in. But at a fast-food joint, you're taking dinner orders, handling money, touching beef and related meat products -- I mean, this is my one square meal of the day, so the fact that some pimply teenager with a Clearasil fix is coordinating this culinary effort sort of takes the bite out of my appetite.)

_____ Monday Morning _____
 Paul Newman
A look back at the weekend and a look ahead at the coming week's action with a fresh new edge.

Norman Chad's Couch Slouch
Starting Lineup
The Chat: "JAG" star David James Elliott
7 Days
The Review: "Major League Baseball 2K5" for Xbox and PlayStation2

_____ The Quote _____
"She doesn't buy jewelry. She doesn't buy dresses. She buys insurance."

-- Actor Paul Newman, on the attitude of his wife, Joanne Woodward, toward his love of auto racing.

_____ Monday Morning Poll _____
If the weather is warm and the jonquils are in bloom, it must be time for the pros' version of spring football -- the NFL draft. Which player is most likely to be the first chosen by the San Francisco 49ers?
Mike Williams
Ronnie Brown
Braylon Edwards
Carnell Williams
Cedric Benson
Someone else

  View results

Note: This is an unscientific survey of washingtonpost.com readers.



The NBA commissioner's position might be good business for the NBA -- it allows the NCAA marketing machine to create marquee names for the league and keeps owners from signing high-risk youngsters to long-term contracts -- but I believe it violates one of the basic tenets of American life:

You do what you want to do whenever you want to do it with whomever you want to do it.

That -- and greed -- pretty much has defined America since, oh, the mid-1770s or so.

Pacers forward Jermaine O'Neal -- who went to the NBA in 1996 straight from high school -- disagreed with Stern's aim, saying: "You don't hear about it in baseball or hockey. To say you have to be 20, 21 to get in the league, it's unconstitutional. If I can go to the U.S. Army and fight the war at 18, why can't you play basketball for 48 minutes and go home?"

Indeed, at 18, you can vote for president, drive in the fast lane and fight in foreign lands, but if you want to play-for-pay in the NBA, it's a moral quandary. Then again, as for O'Neal asking why you can't just play ball "and go home," the problem is many NBA players don't go home after the game; they go to someone else's home and, nine months later, they're sending one of their posse to Target for Huggies.

The sporting public is fickle on this issue. Fans marveled at Mary Lou Retton as a gold medal gymnast at 15, Michelle Wie playing the LPGA Tour at 13, Freddy Adu in MLS at 14. But when a high school star wants to play in the NBA, it threatens the very fabric of this nation's values. Part of this is the need we have to embrace the mythology of intercollegiate sports. We love celebrating the student-athlete, that great balance of mind and body wandering our idyllic, hilly campuses of higher learning, when, in fact, college basketball and college football have absolutely, positively nothing to do with college.

(Of course, the exception is Duke, because Coach K doesn't just teach basketball, he teaches life skills -- and proper management of revenue from American Express commercials.)

Anyway, we should embrace these prodigies, not encumber them.

After all, Yo-Yo Ma made his cello debut at the age of 5.

Pablo Picasso exhibited his first works at 13.

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart began composing at 5.

Jackie Earle Haley played Kelly in "The Bad News Bears" at 14.

(Personal Note I: Not to brag, but I was watching television at 15 months, knew how to use the clicker by age 2 and could program a Betamax VCR by age 3. In addition, I gave a series of instructional seminars on the mute button as a first-grader.)

(Personal Note II: If Stern were commissioner of journalism, Couch Slouch might not be here today. Heck, if I couldn't pursue newspaper work as an adolescent, I might've turned to a life of three-card monte and Metamucil.)

(Personal Note III: I started earning a sportswriting paycheck at 16. My first written words as a professional: "Larry Bird might be the best shooter in all of French Lick, but his total basketball game is so lacking, it appears he's either on the road to nowhere or on the road to Burger King.")

The bottom line? There should be no age minimums or mandatory retirement ages. If you can do the job, you should get the job, though, to be frank, I believe Charo is getting a little long in the tooth.

Ask The Slouch

Q. So Mitch Albom was suspended by the Detroit Free Press for fabricating that Mateen Cleaves and Jason Richardson attended the Final Four when, in fact, they weren't there. Should he lose his job? (Steve Jacobson; Richmond)

A. Not that I am about to start the Mitch Albom Legal Defense Fund, but I wouldn't fire him over this. I'd just make him read "Tuesdays With Morrie."

Q. Who do you blame more for the Fenway Park incident -- the Red Sox fan or Gary Sheffield? (Rick Avery; DeKalb, Ill.)

A. We are a nation in cultural decline, largely traceable to the day Johnny Depp trashed a $1,200-a-night New York City hotel room in 1994.

Q. I graduate next month. Any ideas on what I can do with a degree in sports management, or did I just waste four years and $100,000? (Bobby Cantwell; Orlando)

A. I hope you kept a receipt.

You, too, can enter the $1.25 Ask The Slouch Cash Giveaway. E-mail asktheslouch@aol.com and, if your question is used, you win $1.25 in cash!


© 2005 The Washington Post Company