washingtonpost.com  > World > Asia/Pacific > Southeast Asia > Thailand

78 Thai Muslims Die After Protest

Men Suffocated Or Were Crushed In Army Trucks

By Ellen Nakashima
Washington Post Foreign Service
Wednesday, October 27, 2004; Page A18

JAKARTA, Indonesia, Oct. 26 -- At least 78 Muslim men suffocated or were crushed to death in southern Thailand on Monday as they were being taken to military barracks in packed army trucks after a demonstration, Thai officials said Tuesday.

The news, coming a day after officials said six people were killed when security forces tried to break up the protest, sparked fears of further violence in the already tense south. Muslims, an aggrieved minority in the largely Buddhist country, outnumber Buddhists in that region.


Soldiers arrested hundreds of protesters Monday after they clashed with police in southern Thailand, a majority-Muslim area. (Reuters)

The death toll of at least 84 was Thailand's second highest for an incident this year. On April 28, an assault by security forces killed at least 112 people, most of them Muslims. This week's incident was the latest sign that Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra's campaign to quell a 10-month rebellion in the south is failing. The growing crisis could threaten his reelection.

Monday's protest began when hundreds of residents gathered outside a police station in Tak Bai, a district in Narathiwat province, demanding the release of six men accused of giving weapons to Islamic insurgents. Military officials said the crowd ranged from 1,500 to 2,000 people. Army officials said more than 1,300 were detained.


A Justice Ministry official, Manit Sutaporn, told reporters in Pattani that the 78 detainees likely suffocated from being piled on top of each other in the trucks. "We found no wounds on their bodies," he said.

A forensic expert at the ministry, Pornthip Rojanasunan, said the men could have been gagged to death. "They might have had something stuffed in their mouths or nostrils," she told reporters.

"I'm absolutely shocked," said Ahmad Somboon Bualang, a sociologist and retired university lecturer in Pattani. "For people to die like this during Ramadan, in the Muslim fasting month, is tragic. Suffocating to death is . . . more violent than being shot to death. These people suffered greatly in dying."

Television news Tuesday showed rows of mostly young men sprawled on the ground, roped together with their shirts off and hands tied behind their backs. The scene was apparently filmed before the men were placed in trucks to be taken to an army barracks in Pattani, about 60 miles north of Tak Bai.

Thaksin went to the site of the protest and ordered the military to disperse the crowd, a security analyst said. At least 300 troops with assault weapons surrounded the protesters, firing a water cannon, tear gas and live rounds. The demonstrators threw stones, according to wire service reports.

Thaksin suggested Tuesday that the detainees could have died because they were "weak" from fasting during Ramadan, the Associated Press reported.

[On Wednesday, the prime minister acknowledged security forces had made mistakes in their handling of the riot and voiced regret at the loss of life, according to Reuters.

["I can say that the government resorted to gentle measures and did not use force in suppressing the protesters," Thaksin told parliament. "But mistakes happened during the transfer of the arrested people to trucks."]

The government's handling of the incident has prompted fresh concerns of human rights abuses. Natalie Hill, deputy Asia director for Amnesty International, said the allegations that authorities used excessive force to quell the protest "must be immediately investigated." She said that all deaths related to the incident should be investigated and that anyone suspected of being involved with the deaths should be suspended from duty and brought to justice.

Some analysts said they believed the death toll could rise further and might include extrajudicial killings.


CONTINUED    1 2    Next >

© 2004 The Washington Post Company